9/11’s Longest Battle: Responders Are Aging, Sicker—and the Death Toll Keeps Rising

By Daniel Brooks|Global Trade and Policy Correspondent
•
9/11’s Longest Battle: Responders Are Aging, Sicker—and the Death Toll Keeps Rising

NEW YORK — A generation after the Sept. 11 attacks, the deadliest chapter of 9/11 is still being written. New federal data shows that 9,677 people have died with a confirmed 9/11-related illness—more than three times the 2,977 people killed by terrorists at the World Trade Center, the Pentagon, in Pennsylvania, and aboard the four hijacked jets.

The figures, from the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention and current as of July 2026, count only deceased participants in the World Trade Center Health Program whose 9/11 illnesses were certified. Advocates and physicians say that means the true toll is almost certainly higher, because the program’s list of covered conditions continues to evolve and many deaths may not yet have been linked officially to toxic exposure.

It is a grim milestone 25 years later—and one unlikely to stop soon.

Today, the fight over 9/11 illness is unfolding on two fronts. Scientists are still debating which diseases should be presumed to stem from exposure to the dust, fumes, and chemicals at Ground Zero. At the same time, 9/11 health advocates, lawmakers, and first responders are raising alarms about rounds of cuts, threatened cuts, and partial restorations at the federal program that cares for the sick and at the agencies that support it.

For responders and survivors, time is not neutral. Many who rushed into the rubble and ash are now in their 60s. The average age of responders is 63. About 10,000 responders and survivors have enrolled in the WTC Health Program each year for the past three years. Higher cancer rates are being documented, and other conditions—cognitive impairment, autoimmune disorders, heart disease—are emerging.

“It’s still relevant because there are still thousands of people impacted by this and dying,” said Benjamin Chevat, executive director of 9/11 Health Watch, a nonprofit that monitors the government program’s performance.

The WTC Health Program was created by the James Zadroga 9/11 Health and Compensation Act of 2010 to provide monitoring and treatment for people sickened by exposures during and after the attacks. It serves those exposed at Ground Zero and, since 2024, responders who served at the Pentagon and near the Shanksville, Pennsylvania, crash site. Most enrollees live in New York, but the program has members in all 50 states.

A program under strain

Under President Donald Trump and HHS Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr., advocates, families, and elected officials say repeated staffing cuts and restorations at the WTC Health Program, the CDC, and the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health have destabilized the system.

Kennedy has pledged to bring the program to full staffing. But Chevat said the effects are already visible. Fewer workers at the CDC and NIOSH, which help administer the WTC Health Program, mean delayed enrollment and certification for people waiting on treatment. Staffing upheaval has also slowed the complicated process for adding new medical conditions to the program’s coverage list, he added.

In August 2026, the WTC Health Center Program had 98 employees, according to advocates, though it was designed to operate with 120. HHS told the USA TODAY Network that the program “has the staff and resources needed to fulfill its mission and meet its responsibilities to the responders and survivors it serves.”

Dr. David Prezant, chief medical officer for the New York City Fire Department and codirector of the FDNY WTC Medical Program, said the program must be fully staffed across research, administration, and clinical care so it can pivot quickly as the 9/11 community’s needs change.

He was among the doctors who pushed back recently when ischemic heart disease was rejected for WTC Health Program coverage.

“Our petitions are not about compassion, although as physicians we are compassionate,” Prezant said. “We are basing it on scientific evidence.”

That approach, he said, is what the nation owes responders “who ran into the towers even though they knew they were falling.”

Restoring and hiring for federal positions is likely to be slow, Prezant added. “I don’t expect them to get up to manpower for at least a year,” he said.

There are some signs of rebuilding. Last month, the first WTC Health Program research webinar was held after the monthly event was canceled in 2025. Capt. Mateusz Karwowski of the CDC told medical providers and 9/11 families on an Aug. 13 Zoom call, “We’ve really been looking forward to re-engaging with you.”

Leadership and funding battles

Dr. John Howard, the NIOSH director and WTC Health Program administrator, was reappointed to a six-year term in September after months of concern that Kennedy would let him go. Howard had already been fired by Kennedy and returned to the top job only after an outcry from 9/11 advocates and elected officials from both parties. In July, more than two dozen members of Congress signed a bipartisan letter urging Kennedy to reappoint him.

Prezant praised Howard’s return. “One of the only reasons we have been able to keep running is Dr. Howard,” he said. “It’s critical in this moment in time that he stays. Consistency, experience, sound judgment … he’s really been the bedrock of consistency.”

The turbulence has been years in the making. In February 2025, Elon Musk’s Department of Government Efficiency proposed slashing CDC staff; bipartisan pressure helped reverse the threat. Two months later, Kennedy instituted cuts at NIOSH and fired Howard. After more public and political backlash, the cuts and Howard’s job were restored.

In March 2026, New York officials—including Gov. Kathy Hochul—and members of Congress again pushed back amid reports that WTC Health Program employees had been reassigned to other agencies, including U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement. Republican lawmakers wrote to Kennedy demanding answers, saying staffing levels were “well below authorized capacity” even as enrollment grew, leading to delays in treatment authorizations, claims backlogs, disrupted care, and reduced contractor oversight.

In May 2026, Kennedy told a U.S. Senate committee that the agency had made “a couple of mistakes” and promised to fix staffing shortages and lift a hiring freeze. HHS said it remains committed “to supporting the long-term health and well-being of the 9/11 community.”

Meanwhile, the 9/11 community has won a measure of stability: both the Zadroga Victims Compensation Fund and the WTC Health Program now have more secure funding, after President Donald Trump signed legislation intended to carry them through 2090. At this year’s World Trade Center memorial ceremony, for the first time, a seventh bell will toll for those who have died from 9/11-related health effects in the years since—and for those still to come.

Chevat said advocates remain vigilant. He described the program as still wading through “chaos” caused by Kennedy, whose leadership of HHS remains controversial. “With the 25th anniversary of 9/11 approaching, Secretary Kennedy should do one less cooking show and spend that time fixing the problems he has caused,” Chevat said.

The science of exposure

At Mount Sinai’s World Trade Center Health Program Clinical Center of Excellence, Dr. Michael Crane, the medical director, is focused on what comes next. A specialist in occupational health, Crane has explained that 9/11 exposures were in many ways the opposite of typical workplace exposures.

“Look at the people who walked through it, literally caked in dust,” Crane said, recalling images from Ground Zero after the towers fell. “Each of these people were wearing a building. They’re wearing the cement, they’re wearing the asbestos materials.”

Facemask filters clogged so quickly with dust that many responders could not replace them fast enough, he said.

Many illnesses linked to those exposures have long latency periods. Prezant, a pulmonologist, pointed to an increase in pulmonary fibrosis, which usually appears 20 to 30 years after particulate exposure. “Right on time, unfortunately, we’re seeing that,” he said. In four years, the FDNY Clinical Center of Excellence has had eight lung transplants among 9/11 responders.

WTC health studies have also shown that the incidence of prostate cancer is up to 40% higher among 9/11 rescue and recovery workers than in the general population. Responders also face up to a 43% increased risk of melanoma. Prezant also worries about ischemic heart disease and autoimmune diseases, which are not covered for treatment by the WTC Health Program. The program now covers uterine cancer, but for some responders and survivors the change came too late.

Richard Palmer, a former New York City Department of Correction employee who responded to Ground Zero on Sept. 11, 2001, said he was disappointed by the rejection of ischemic heart disease coverage. Palmer receives WTC-related care for asthma and other respiratory conditions, but not for the heart disease he manages after a 2006 quadruple bypass and follow-up treatments.

“I’ll never talk bad about the health program,” said Palmer, who repeatedly joined responders in lobbying Congress for the Zadroga Act and WTC Health Program funding. “But I don’t really understand the reason why cardiac isn’t added. Money was put away to research all these illnesses. Why is it not going anywhere?”

Crane said his future concerns for the 9/11 cohort include dementia disorders. Depression, anxiety, and the “mind in overdrive” that post-traumatic stress disorder can bring are also associated with cognitive impairment later in life. He called the Zadroga Act’s inclusion of mental health coverage “a lifesaver.”

“If you were down there and you saw what you saw, it was shocking,” Crane said. “Many responders describe symptoms consistent with PTSD. Many other responders develop depression to require treatment from the program.”

Chevat, a former chief of staff for Rep. Carolyn Maloney, D-N.Y., during the fights to create Zadroga, said doctors have explained the fallout this way: “Most exposures to cancer are small amounts over a long period of time. This is a large amount over a short period of time. You’re basically bathing in toxins.”

Proving causal connections can take decades. “The epidemiologist who is going to prove this isn’t born yet,” Chevat said.

Care that saves lives

Advocates and medical experts say the WTC Health Program’s quality of care saves lives and preserves quality of life. Prezant said that at his FDNY center, 86% of those who developed cancer are alive five years later, compared with 63% of people with a cancer diagnosis in New York state, a measure that accounts for cancer type and age at diagnosis.

Crane said data show that 9/11 patients with specific conditions often have better outcomes than the general public because of care delivered through the WTC Centers of Excellence in the New York City metro area and a national network across the country.

A recent study found that responders enrolled in the WTC Health Program had a 13% lower risk of death from any cause than 9/11 responders who were not in the program, which offers health screenings and treatment for 9/11-related illnesses. The findings suggest regular monitoring, access to treatment, and preventive care help enrolled responders live longer and healthier lives.

“Some of our researchers have compared our mortality compared statewide,” Crane said. “We tend to find that our patients are actually doing fairly well.”

Because the program offers supportive health initiatives such as smoking cessation, Crane said, participants get care, support, and advice. Just 4% of program participants smoke, compared with New York state’s adult smoking rate of 9.3%, itself a historic low.

“It’s all about where you are, who’s caring for you, your support network,” Crane said. “World Trade, I think, gives responders and survivors a place to get support and advice.”

That success, he said, makes it even more important to track emerging 9/11-related illnesses. “We’re not done here. We are definitely not done here,” Crane said. When new health threats emerge, he added, “We have to be here too with the tools to help them.”

Or, as 9/11 health advocates have put it: Never forget means never forget.

Nancy Cutler covers People & Policy. Reach her at [email protected]; follow her on X, Bluesky and Instagram at @nancyrockland.

This article originally appeared on Rockland/Westchester Journal News: 9/11 illness fight expands as responders get older, sicker.

Share

This Post Has 0 Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!

Leave a Reply