Alex Murdaugh Returns to Court as Evidence Fight Intensifies Ahead of Murder Retrial

Alex Murdaugh is expected in a South Carolina courtroom Friday, where prosecutors and his defense team will resume a widening fight over evidence ahead of his April retrial on two murder charges.
The 58-year-old former lawyer is scheduled to stand trial again in the June 2021 shooting deaths of his wife, Maggie, and their younger son, Paul, at the family’s home in Colleton County. He is set to appear Friday while serving a lengthy prison sentence after pleading guilty to stealing from clients.
The South Carolina Supreme Court overturned Murdaugh’s convictions, ruling that a court clerk improperly influenced jurors during his 2023 trial. The clerk told jurors to watch Murdaugh’s body language and not be fooled when he testified in his own defense.
During Friday’s hearing, both sides are expected to clash over whether defense DNA experts can test the remainder of a genetic sample found under Maggie Murdaugh’s fingernails. They also are expected to argue over whether authorities must turn over ballistics and other evidence from shootings in eight surrounding counties involving the same type of gun as one of the weapons used in the killings.
Much less may be said publicly about the most closely watched dispute of all: whether prosecutors have convened a grand jury to investigate a police officer who was friends with Murdaugh. Defense lawyers say prosecutors have suggested the officer arrived at Murdaugh’s home before other law enforcement officers and could have helped him hide bloody clothes or the weapons used in the killings. Neither the clothes nor the weapons have been found.
Prosecutors declined to say whether any such evidence exists, citing legal restrictions on disclosing whether a grand jury is meeting.
The defense argues the issue is critical because prosecutors told the first jury that Murdaugh acted alone. Prosecutors said no one else was at the home between the killings and Murdaugh’s return from visiting his mother, when he called 911 to report the shootings. If another person was involved, defense lawyers say, that would cast doubt on witness testimony from the 2023 trial that Murdaugh acted alone. They have demanded any evidence prosecutors have of possible accomplices or a related grand jury investigation.
The pretrial filings have grown increasingly acrimonious. After Murdaugh’s lawyers accused the state of not sharing cellphone data, prosecutors wrote that it was hard to understand the ‘inexplicably brazen and highly prejudicial falsehoods’ in the defense’s public filings, adding: ‘It is stunning, really. Facts matter.’ When prosecutors later offered all the data from a computerized scan of the crime scene before the hearing, Murdaugh’s lawyers responded that the defense was glad to hear it and wished the state had said so a month earlier.
While the pretrial hearing is being held in Lexington County, the retrial has been moved to Sumter County, east of Columbia and about 80 miles (129 kilometers) from Colleton County. Judge Debra McCaslin determined that extensive publicity surrounding the case in Murdaugh’s home county could prevent a fair retrial.
The killings of Murdaugh’s wife and son and his subsequent six-week trial captivated the true-crime world with a mix of treachery, corruption, money, power and Southern accents. The April retrial will again draw intense scrutiny, but the hearing Friday is unlikely to resolve the central question of guilt; instead, it will help determine what evidence jurors hear and how much room the defense has to challenge the state’s account that Murdaugh acted alone.
Regardless of what happens in his next murder trial, Murdaugh will remain in prison. He pleaded guilty to stealing around $12 million from his clients and is currently serving a 40-year federal sentence concurrently with a 27-year state sentence for his financial crimes.
