Austin Woman Sues Torchy's Tacos, Alleging a Cow Tooth Ended Up in Her Taco

An Austin woman has sued Torchy's Tacos, alleging she found a cow tooth inside a takeout taco—an object the chain later confirmed was a cow tooth.
Nohemi Castillo filed the lawsuit Oct. 13 against Torchy's Tacos and Success Foods Management Group LLC, which does business as Torchy's Tacos, according to FOX 7 Austin. The complaint stems from a June 9 visit to the chain's location at 1822 S. Congress Ave., where Castillo ordered a Democrat taco made with beef barbacoa.
Castillo says she nearly swallowed what appeared to be a cow tooth. She was grossed out and sickened by the discovery and saw a doctor that evening, receiving prescription medication, the outlet reported.
She is seeking up to $250,000 in damages, alleging negligence, breach of implied warranties, and violations of the Texas Deceptive Trade Practices Act and the federal Food Safety Modernization Act, according to FOX 7 and KVUE. USA TODAY reached out to Castillo's attorney, Scott Vasquez, for additional comment on the lawsuit and the allegations.
The Democrat taco includes beef barbacoa, avocado, cotija cheese, cilantro, diced onions and tomatillo salsa, according to the restaurant's menu.
Castillo's lawsuit reportedly includes a photograph of the tooth and alleges Torchy's failed to properly inspect and prepare its food to prevent foreign objects from entering the product. The filing also alleges that a manager at the South Congress location was notified of the incident but questions whether the manager took action to address the problem, according to FOX 7.
Vasquez told KVUE he believed the tooth should have been detected before the food reached the customer.
'It could choke somebody. It really could,' Vasquez told the outlet.
A Torchy's Tacos spokesperson told KXAN and KVUE that the company investigated Castillo's complaint and confirmed the object was a cow tooth.
'We source the highest quality food available, which means our barbacoa comes from natural beef cheek that we source from a supplier,' the spokesperson said in a statement.
The company said such incidents can occur during meat processing but are rare. It also said it had partnered with its supplier to reinforce internal procedures and help prevent similar incidents.
Vasquez told KVUE he was disappointed with how the company handled the complaint and hoped it would take responsibility.
USA TODAY reached out to Torchy's Tacos for additional comment on the lawsuit and its allegations.
The lawsuit is a civil claim, and no finding of liability has been made. Still, the case underscores the reputational and legal risks restaurants face when customers allege foreign objects in food. Those complaints can prompt reviews of supplier screening, kitchen procedures and complaint-response practices—issues that can affect customer trust as well as regulatory exposure.
Reporter Anthony Thompson can be reached at [email protected], or on X @athompsonUSAT
This article originally appeared on USA TODAY: Texas woman sues Torchy's Tacos after finding cow tooth in taco
