Cornell’s Early Decision Season Jolted by Sexual Assault Lawsuit as Families Weigh Safety and Prestige

By Michael Turner|Senior Markets Correspondent
•
Cornell’s Early Decision Season Jolted by Sexual Assault Lawsuit as Families Weigh Safety and Prestige

ITHACA, N.Y. — As college admissions season hits its fall peak, Cornell University is facing an uncomfortable question from the families it hopes to attract: Is this still a school worth applying to?

The question has grown more urgent in recent weeks, after a former Cornell student filed a lawsuit alleging she was the victim of a 2024 gang rape at the university’s Chi Phi fraternity house. The former student, identified in court papers as Jane Doe, once considered Cornell her dream school, according to her attorney. Now, as students lead protests on campus and faculty members consider a vote of no confidence in the administration, the next class of potential Cornell applicants is entering the height of application season with uncertainty.

It is still too early to know what the lawsuit will mean for the university or its admissions. But with less than three weeks until Cornell’s Nov. 1 early decision deadline — when seniors who want Cornell above all other schools submit a binding application — prospective applicants, their parents and their counselors are rethinking the process in real time.

In parent groups, on college admissions forums and across social media, many families are asking whether students should still apply early, wait until the Jan. 2 regular-decision deadline, or drop Cornell altogether, even if that means starting from scratch. Admissions strategists often encourage early applications because they can improve an applicant’s odds, but this year the calculation feels different for some families.

Robert Schwartz, founder of YourBestCollegeEssay, said five high school seniors have told him in the past few weeks that they are changing their plans. All of them, he said, are girls who no longer intend to apply to Cornell. Schwartz has helped students prepare for the admissions process for 15 years. “I’ve never seen anything like this,” he said.

Roland, a high school senior in Minnesota, had planned to apply early to Cornell through the QuestBridge scholarship program. He had already started writing his supplemental essays and called the university “a dream.” But after reading details of the alleged rape, he said, “it really grossed me out,” and he removed Cornell from his list. CNN allowed parents and students concerned about hurting their college admission chances to use pseudonyms.

“I don’t know that I would feel safe in an environment that handles drugging situations like that as poorly as Cornell did,” Roland said.

He said he does not know other students who are dropping Cornell, but everyone at his high school is discussing the case. At a college fair featuring hundreds of schools, Roland lingered for about three hours and did not see anyone approach the Cornell booth.

“Everyone’s Snapchat stories, everyone’s Instagram notes, for the past week or so have been about this topic,” he said. “Everyone’s outraged about it.”

When asked for comment, a Cornell spokesperson pointed to a public letter published Tuesday by university President Michael Kotlikoff, in which he apologized to Jane Doe and outlined changes aimed at improving campus safety and sexual assault reporting. Among the changes, Kotlikoff announced that Cornell was suspending parties and social events at on-campus fraternity houses for the rest of the year.

Michele, the parent of a high school senior, said her son was drawn to Cornell’s prestige and had planned to apply regular decision. After news of the investigation, she said, her son was “disheartened,” and the family decided to look elsewhere.

“A university’s reputation and academic prestige are important,” she said, “but they are not more important than character, personal responsibility, and feeling confident in the environment where your child will spend four years.”

Rachel Rubin, founder and CEO of Spark Admissions, said her firm has had more than a dozen calls with families who raised concerns about campus safety and culture at Cornell. Two families, she said, specifically chose to apply somewhere other than Cornell for early decision.

Elizabeth Stone, CEO of the college application counseling firm Top Tier Admissions, said a “handful” of her clients reached out to discuss the investigation. A few students who had planned to apply early decision to Cornell have redirected to other schools — in the “single digits,” she said.

Schwartz said he asked the students who were dropping Cornell whether they were doing so for safety reasons. “They started saying, ‘Yeah, it’s safety, but then enough is enough,’” he said. “That’s how you make change, is when a group en masse says ‘No, I’m not going to go there.’”

Demonstrators at the Washington Monument hold signs during a “Stop Sexual Violence” protest, one of several rallies held in response to the Cornell University rape allegations. Photo: Annabelle Gordon/Reuters

Samrawet, the mother of a New Jersey high school senior, said Cornell would have been a convenient location, but her son is “disgusted with all this craziness.” Three other kids she knows are refusing to apply, too, she said.

“I honestly don’t understand why a family would choose to apply to Cornell after learning about such a serious situation involving students,” she said.

Even among students who are not applying to Cornell, Stone said, families who once focused mainly on a college’s academic profile may now look more closely at campus safety and how their top choices might handle a similar situation.

“Families are looking more holistically at the history of the institution and what goes on other college campuses,” Stone said. “Cornell is not the only place where terrible things happen.”

Dropping a college at this stage in the admissions process can be a loaded decision, and it is not always clear cut. Cornell is among the less difficult Ivy League schools to get into, and it is known for its top engineering program, while also being one of the few Ivies with a business school open to undergraduates. It is an enticing option for students looking for a pre-professional major, Rubin said.

It is also the largest Ivy League school by undergraduate population, with more than 16,000 students, which can appeal to those seeking the experience of a larger school without giving up top academics. But its location in relatively isolated Ithaca, New York, means social activities tend to center on parties and Greek life, Rubin said.

Charis Ralko, an admissions consultant at Ivy Coach, said she has not had any students drop Cornell. Only one parent called to vent about the university’s response to the lawsuit, but that parent’s son was still planning to apply early decision.

“Students’ applications are just about complete. We’re just proofing, putting the final touches on them,” Ralko said. “It’s a little late to just pick up and totally abandon their original plan.”

Miles, a high school senior in Utah, has wanted to attend Cornell “my entire life,” he said. The small college town appealed to him, as did the larger student body and the School of Industrial and Labor Relations. News of the lawsuit and the details of Cornell’s handling of the initial investigation turned his dream “on its head.”

“I do not want to be in a place that the administration is supporting rapists instead of victims,” he said.

Miles said he agonized over the choice for three days before ultimately deciding to still apply early decision. Seeing faculty members and students protest and rally behind Jane Doe showed him Cornell was actually “a place that I want to be,” he said. He was especially encouraged by conversations with current Cornell students, who told him the campus needs more people who are appalled by the news.

“We shouldn’t be deterring people that are against sexual assault from going to Cornell, or the school is going to become a terrible school,” Miles recalled them saying. “It still needs to have the people that will participate in seven-hour sit-ins and leave their classes to fight for student rights.”

Current Cornell students told Miles: “We shouldn’t be deterring people that are against sexual assault from going to Cornell.” Photo: Surya Vaidy/CNN

Not every student is citing principles in their choice. Miles said one of his friends decided to drop his early decision application to Cornell, not because of the incident itself, but for fear the school’s reputation would be damaged.

Ralko recalled a parent asking whether it might be easier to get into Cornell this year because of the news — an inquiry so routine after college scandals that Ralko even has a name for such families: “Squeakers,” because they think they can squeak in during what they perceive as a less competitive year.

And in an increasingly competitive undergraduate admissions landscape, top schools remain somewhat scandal-proof. In 2006, Duke University’s administration attributed a slight decline in student admission acceptances — an estimated three percentage points, still within the university’s usual range — to the school’s lacrosse rape scandal, which was later revealed to be a hoax. In 2014, Emma Sulkowicz publicly criticized Columbia University’s handling of her sexual assault case, a protest that became widely publicized when Sulkowicz carried a mattress throughout campus and drew support from figures like Sen. Kirsten Gillibrand. Applications still increased in 2015; more recently, Columbia has received its largest applicant pool on record.

Linda Kern, a Cornell alum who has been a college admissions counselor for eight years, said no students have brought up the Cornell case to her, nor have any decided to toss their applications. She doubts the case will dissuade students or parents. Most people recognize this can happen on any campus, she said, and many kids applying may not think that what happened to Jane Doe could also happen to them.

“It’s kind of like when you see a natural disaster on the news: ‘Well, that happened in that community, but it’s not going to affect me,’” she said.

And Cornell is still an Ivy League school. For many families and their kids, “the overriding consideration is prestige.”

“They believe that these schools will set them up for life,” Kern said. “And to a degree, there’s some truth to that.”

For more CNN news and newsletters, create an account at CNN.com.

Share

This Post Has 0 Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!

Leave a Reply