Deep Value or Value Trap? The Bull Case for Ad-Tech's Criteo Amid Market Skepticism
In the often-volatile world of advertising technology, Criteo S.A. (NASDAQ: CRTO) finds itself in a curious position: a company generating substantial cash flow, yet priced by the market as if its best days are firmly in the past. A detailed bullish analysis, originally surfaced on the r/ValueInvesting subreddit, argues this deep skepticism has created a compelling opportunity for patient investors.
As of late January, Criteo shares traded around $19.76, putting its trailing and forward price-to-earnings ratios at a mere 6.69 and 4.48, respectively. On an enterprise value basis, it trades at approximately 3.7x EBIT. These multiples sit near historical lows, even as the company maintains a robust net cash position of about $161 million against a market capitalization hovering near $1 billion.
The market's bearish stance is largely anchored in concerns over Criteo's legacy Performance Media business. This segment, which drives the majority of revenue, relies heavily on third-party cookies and is exposed to browser policy changes, most notably Google's long-anticipated—and repeatedly delayed—phasing out of third-party cookies in Chrome.
"The narrative is simple: cookies die, Criteo dies," says Marcus Thorne, a portfolio manager at a mid-sized hedge fund. "But that narrative ignores two critical facts. First, Google has both regulatory and self-interest reasons not to completely demolish the ecosystem. Second, and more importantly, it ignores what Criteo is building."
That "building" refers to Criteo's Retail Media network, a higher-margin business that monetizes first-party shopper data on retailer websites. Growing at roughly 12% annually, this segment now represents about 22% of revenue and is structurally insulated from third-party cookie deprecation. Management is aggressively returning capital to shareholders, repurchasing close to 8% of the market cap annually, a move supported by recent insider buying at market prices.
"The valuation is pricing in a terminal decline," argues Sarah Chen, a fintech analyst and contributor to several investment forums. "But you have a company with a net cash balance sheet, double-digit growth in its future-proof segment, and a management team actively buying back stock. The disconnect is stark. A re-rating to even average historical multiples could imply 50-100% upside from here."
Not everyone is convinced. David Keller, a vocal skeptic on social media, offers a more cynical take: "This is a classic value trap. They're buying back stock because they have no better ideas. The core business is in secular decline, propped up by Google's delays. Retail Media is a bright spot, but it's too small to move the needle before the cookie crumbles for good. That cash on the balance sheet will evaporate trying to fund a pivot."
The debate hinges on the timeline and impact of industry changes versus Criteo's transition speed. Meanwhile, the company continues to invest in its first-party data solutions. For value investors, the central question remains whether the market's deep pessimism has overshot reality, offering a margin of safety that outweighs the known risks.
READ NEXT: The Contrarian Playbook: 30 Stocks Analysts Say Could Double and Beyond the Hype: 11 Under-the-Radar AI Investments
Disclosure: This is an independent market analysis. The author and publisher have no position in CRTO at the time of writing.