Feds Say Illinois Lawyer Used Fake Court Orders to Take $400K From Children’s Settlement Accounts

A federal indictment accuses a Bethalto attorney of using fabricated court orders to withdraw more than $400,000 from settlement accounts created for four minors he was appointed to protect in Madison County.
David Elliot, 41, was indicted on 15 federal bank and mail fraud charges. Prosecutors say the allegations stem from his appointments as a guardian ad litem for three minors in 2016 and for a fourth minor in 2017.
The Circuit Court of Madison County appointed Elliot in 2016 to serve as guardian ad litem for three minors in litigation brought on behalf of their deceased mother. In 2017, the court gave him the same role for another minor in a case involving that child’s deceased father.
A guardian ad litem is appointed to represent a minor’s best interests and to make reports and recommendations to the court. In these cases, Elliot also operated bank accounts established in the minors’ names to hold their settlement proceeds. Prosecutors say his compensation was to be paid before settlement funds were distributed, and any later withdrawal from one of the children’s accounts required a special court order.
The indictment alleges Elliot bypassed that restriction by creating fraudulent court orders that appeared to authorize withdrawals from the minors’ accounts. He allegedly presented the false orders to the bank and withdrew more than $400,000 between May 2019 and October 2022.
Prosecutors have not publicly provided a complete breakdown showing how much was taken from each account or how all of the money was used after it was withdrawn. First Alert 4 reported that two of the minors never received their settlement money and another received only a small portion.
The indictment describes an additional step as one of the minors approached age 18, the point at which the settlement money could be accessed. Prosecutors say Elliot withdrew money from accounts belonging to two other minors and transferred it into the account of the child who was about to turn 18. The government accuses him of making those transfers to conceal earlier missing money before the beneficiary could discover the shortage.
According to the indictment, two of the minors ultimately received none of the settlement funds owed to them, while another received only a small portion. Prosecutors also accuse Elliot of creating a false court order to convince one of the minors that the settlement money could not be accessed until age 21. That purported restriction was not a genuine court order, according to the indictment, and prosecutors say it gave Elliot additional time before the beneficiary could seek access to the account.
The case highlights the unusual level of trust placed in court-appointed representatives who manage money for children. Settlement funds for minors often come from lawsuits tied to a parent’s death or injury and are meant to help cover future needs when the beneficiary becomes an adult. Because the money is usually held under court supervision, families and financial institutions may rely on court orders as proof that a withdrawal is proper. When those orders are allegedly forged, the loss may not become clear until years later, when the child asks for money that is supposed to be waiting.
Families dealing with settlement money held for a child should keep copies of the settlement agreement, account statements and every court order governing when or how the money can be withdrawn. If an attorney presents an unexpected order restricting access or authorizing a withdrawal, the document can be compared with the official court file rather than relying only on the copy supplied by the person managing the funds.
Bank statements can also be reviewed against the court orders authorizing withdrawals. An unexplained transfer, missing balance or restriction that does not appear in the official court record should be raised with the court, the financial institution or independent legal counsel promptly.
Illinois residents who believe a lawyer engaged in dishonest conduct can file a complaint with the Attorney Registration and Disciplinary Commission. The ARDC recommends keeping copies of court papers, receipts, letters and other records that support a complaint.
The ARDC also operates a Client Protection Program for certain losses caused by dishonest conduct by Illinois lawyers. The program can reimburse eligible losses of up to $150,000 per loss, subject to its requirements, including that the lawyer has been disciplined or has died and that the claimant has made reasonable efforts to pursue other available recovery.
The indictment contains accusations that have not been proven in court. Elliot is presumed innocent unless convicted.
Each federal bank fraud charge carries a maximum possible sentence of 30 years in prison and a fine of up to $1 million. Mail fraud carries a maximum of 20 years in prison and a fine of up to $250,000. Those are statutory maximum penalties rather than a prediction of Elliot’s sentence if he is convicted. Any punishment would be determined by the federal court based on the charges of conviction and applicable sentencing rules.
Elliot’s jury trial is currently scheduled for November 9 at the federal courthouse in Benton, Illinois.
Image Credit: Shutterstock.
