Judge Extends Block on Trump’s Renovation Plan for East Potomac Golf Course

By Daniel Brooks|Global Trade and Policy Correspondent
•
Judge Extends Block on Trump’s Renovation Plan for East Potomac Golf Course

WASHINGTON (AP) — A federal judge on Monday extended an order blocking the Trump administration from moving ahead with renovations to a century-old public golf course in the nation’s capital, prolonging a legal fight that has grown well beyond the fairway.

U.S. District Judge Ana Reyes issued a preliminary injunction that temporarily bars the government from removing or damaging any additional trees at East Potomac Golf Course. While the lawsuit is pending, the administration must give 10 days’ written notice before making any “irreparable modification” to any “forms or features” of the course.

In her ruling, Reyes repeated an earlier line that has become central to the case: “I am not the Lorax. I do not speak for the trees. The Court still does not speak for the trees. It speaks only for the rule of law.”

Reyes also expressed astonishment that the government had asked her not to believe the sitting president and to disregard Trump’s public statements about his plans for the golf course.

“This started as a case about golf. That good walk spoiled. But it has become much more,” she wrote. “It now forces the Court to reconcile assertions by President Donald J. Trump with the sworn testimony of multiple government employees and the argument of senior Department of Justice attorneys.”

The dispute centers on Trump’s Oct. 18 announcement on social media that the course would close for 15 months beginning Nov. 15 and that the 106-year-old park and course would be redeveloped despite a court challenge by the D.C. Preservation League and two golfers. A day later, Trump posted that work would begin immediately.

Reyes, who was nominated to the bench by Democratic President Joe Biden, had previously ordered the administration to suspend work on the project until at least Oct. 26. Monday’s preliminary injunction extends that protection while the case proceeds, though it does not resolve the merits of the lawsuit. The injunction is temporary and does not decide the case, but it preserves the status quo while the court weighs claims that the administration moved ahead without adequate notice and caused irreversible harm. The case has also become a broader test of how courts treat a president’s public statements when they conflict with sworn testimony from government employees and arguments from Justice Department lawyers.

Trump was asked about the case late Monday as he returned to Joint Base Andrews in Maryland after a rally in Mississippi. He indicated that work on the course would proceed as planned.

“It has the go-ahead. The judge feels that she would like to approve it as it goes along. And I didn’t know she was an architectural critic of golf courses,” Trump said sarcastically.

He added of the judge: “She knows nothing about that, so we’ll appeal that,” while also calling his planned overhaul a “beautiful project for Washington, D.C.”

Trump later reiterated in a social media post his Oct. 18 statement that the course would close for 15 months. “We are closing the East Potomac Golf Course Site as scheduled on November 15th in order to renovate and rebuild for Competitive (with other such projects!), Safety, Modernization, and Aesthetic reasons,” he wrote.

The plaintiffs — the DC Preservation League and two golfers — claim the work is inflicting irreversible damage. At a hearing, the judge sharply criticized the government after workers cut down at least 400 trees over a holiday weekend with little notice to the plaintiffs.

The renovation is part of the Republican president’s broader campaign to leave his personal imprint on Washington’s historic landscape. Those plans include a large ballroom at the White House, a massive arch and the creation of a National Garden of American Heroes in West Potomac Park. The DC Preservation League is part of a coalition, including the Cultural Landscape Foundation and one D.C. resident, that has filed lawsuits challenging those plans.

Reyes rejected the administration’s request that she recuse herself from the case. The government had questioned her impartiality and accused her of engaging in “egregious” behavior from the bench during an emergency hearing.

In Monday’s ruling, Reyes stressed that she had hoped the parties could resolve their dispute without judicial intervention. She noted that she had denied the plaintiffs’ previous requests.

“The Court would much prefer not to have to resolve Lorax v. Once-ler redux. Indeed, for months, the Court declined to intervene,” she wrote.

But she said the government forced her hand by bulldozing hundreds of trees without notice, doing “what it assured all it would not do.”

Reyes quoted from a golf-related opinion by the late Supreme Court Justice Antonin Scalia, a conservative icon, in stressing the temporary nature of her decision.

“Here, golf and government have again clashed,” Reyes wrote. “By issuing this preliminary injunction, the Court does not end the round: it simply marks the ball until the parties can fully and fairly litigate this case.”

Skye Perryman, president and CEO of Democracy Forward, whose organization is co-counsel representing the plaintiffs, called the ruling “a big win that will rightly protect East Potomac Park from further irreparable harm.” In an email, she added that the move will stop activities “while the case continues, and we are eager to argue the case in court.”

An earlier version of this story incorrectly referred to Perryman as “he.” This version corrects her identity to “she.”

Associated Press reporters Gary Fields and Will Weissert contributed.

Share

This Post Has 0 Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!

Leave a Reply