Judge Eyes March 2027 for Lindsay Clancy Retrial—If Prosecutors Pursue One

By Daniel Brooks|Global Trade and Policy Correspondent
•
Judge Eyes March 2027 for Lindsay Clancy Retrial—If Prosecutors Pursue One

The judge overseeing the Lindsay Clancy case said Monday he would like to target March 2027 for a retrial, though prosecutors remain unwilling to say whether they will again pursue first-degree murder charges against the Massachusetts mother accused of killing her three children.

The exchange came at the end of a tense court hearing in which lawyers clashed over the earlier mistrial, the conduct of a lone holdout juror and the defense’s public comments. Judge William Sullivan said he would take the arguments under advisement and issue rulings in the coming weeks.

Retrial timeline remains unsettled

Prosecutor Jennifer Sprague said any retrial would depend on how the judge rules on several pending motions. “We’re not at that point yet,” she said.

Defense attorney Kevin Reddington accused prosecutors of stringing everyone along and questioned why they had not decided whether to retry Clancy or what charges she might face.

“I will not have this woman sit in jail for another year or two or three. I want a trial, and I want it with you, and I want it this spring,” he told the judge.

Sullivan asked the parties to meet November 16 to discuss scheduling while he considers defense motions to dismiss the charges and to obtain the holdout juror’s records, as well as the Commonwealth’s request for a gag order.

A case that drew national attention

The hearing was the latest turn in a triple-murder case that became one of the most fiercely debated criminal trials in recent memory before it ended in a mistrial this summer.

Prosecutors argued that Clancy, 36, “acted intentionally, rationally and swiftly” when she strangled her three children in the family’s Duxbury home and attempted suicide in January 2023. Her defense argued that she was suffering from postpartum psychosis at the time and was not criminally responsible for the deaths of Cora, 5; Dawson, 3; and 8-month-old Callan.

The trial put a spotlight on maternal mental health, postpartum psychosis, the internet’s appetite for conspiracy theories and persistent skepticism toward the so-called insanity defense.

After more than a month of testimony, the 12-person jury could not reach a unanimous verdict because of a single holdout juror, leaving an 11-1 split in favor of not guilty by reason of a lack of criminal responsibility. Sullivan declared a mistrial because of the deadlock.

Clancy did not testify. She has been held at Tewksbury Hospital since shortly after the killings and remains partially paralyzed because of her suicide attempt.

She could face life in prison if convicted of murder. If jurors find that she cannot be held criminally responsible, the court would likely begin the process of committing her to a psychiatric hospital.

Prosecutors could retry her on first-degree murder charges, bring lesser charges such as manslaughter, or drop the case altogether. There is also the remote possibility of a plea deal that could end the matter outright.

“I’ll be talking more on November 16,” Plymouth County District Attorney Timothy Cruz said outside court Monday.

Holdout juror dispute turns heated

Since the mistrial, Reddington has filed several motions seeking to prevent a retrial. Clancy appeared in court in late September for the first time since the trial ended, and the parties debated several of those requests.

Monday’s hearing grew sharp when Reddington asked for the holdout juror’s phone records and juror questionnaire form. In making his case, Reddington named the holdout juror, and Sullivan interrupted him to ask that he not do so.

“I’m gonna stop you right there,” Sullivan said.

“No, you’re not gonna stop me,” Reddington replied.

“I am,” Sullivan said.

“No you’re not,” Reddington said.

Sullivan told him to refer to the juror by a pseudonym, but Reddington protested, saying the juror had given interviews on television and in podcasts. “He’s got more face time than I do,” Reddington said.

Reddington then tried to raise the juror’s statements on a jury questionnaire, but Sullivan stopped him and noted that the form is confidential by statute, frustrating the defense attorney.

“I have evidence that this man was not honest on this form,” Reddington alleged, slamming his hand on the podium.

Heather O’Connor, an attorney for the juror, said he did not violate any jury rules and noted that the defense did not object to any issues until after it learned his position on the case. She asked the court to deny the defense request, saying it would send a dangerous message to potential jurors: “Agree with the majority, or potentially be investigated.”

The holdout juror, Michael Péguy Desronvil, has said his position was misrepresented by some fellow jurors who spoke to the press.

Double jeopardy and gag order arguments

Defense attorney Martin G. Weinberg asked the judge to dismiss the charges, arguing that Sullivan improperly declared a mistrial because of a hung jury. A retrial, Weinberg said, would violate Clancy’s protection against double jeopardy.

During deliberations, the jury foreperson sent notes to the court saying that a holdout juror was not following the law. Sullivan called the jurors into the courtroom and asked whether they could follow his instructions on the law and reasonable doubt. Each juror affirmed that they could.

Weinberg argued that Sullivan should have asked more probing questions to get to the bottom of the issue. The judge’s decision not to question the jury further, he said, violated Clancy’s right to a fair jury trial.

“At minimum, these notes required appropriate voir dire,” Weinberg said, referring to the process of questioning jurors. “That voir dire would have included—should have included—a determination of whether or not the 12th juror was deliberating in good faith.”

Sullivan interrupted Weinberg: “Didn’t I do that? Didn’t I do a voir dire? Didn’t I bring the jurors in? Didn’t I swear them in?”

Weinberg said the judge’s question was insufficient. “A single question that led to the assurance by all 12 jurors is simply constitutionally insufficient to probe what was going on in that jury room,” he said.

Prosecutor Sprague countered that the judge properly declared a mistrial. The jury notes indicated that the holdout juror had a disagreement about the evidence rather than improper bias or a personal issue, she argued. Asking probing questions would have been inappropriate and would have violated the secrecy of the jury room, she said.

“It was clear from the record this juror did not refuse to deliberate. He refused to agree,” she said.

Finally, the Commonwealth asked the judge to impose a gag order restricting what the parties can say in public. Sprague said Reddington’s comments about the holdout juror, his relationship with Clancy and a presidential pardon were “calculated to affect public perception of this case.”

“I am not looking for 15 minutes of fame in this case,” Sprague said. “What the Commonwealth wants is justice for Cora, Dawson, and Callan.”

Defense attorney Laura B. McConnell argued against a gag order and said the prosecution’s claims about harm to a potential jury are “purely speculative.” Restricting what Reddington can say would also infringe on Clancy’s rights, she argued.

“He is not only her attorney, he is her voice, too,” she said.

What comes next

The case is likely to remain closely watched, not only because of its legal stakes but because it has become a flashpoint in broader debates over how the criminal justice system treats postpartum psychosis and other maternal mental health crises. For now, the next major marker is the November 16 scheduling conference, where the parties are expected to return to court as Sullivan weighs the competing motions.

This story has been updated with additional information. CNN’s Lauren del Valle contributed to this report.

For more CNN news and newsletters, create an account at CNN.com.

Share

This Post Has 0 Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!

Leave a Reply