Lindsay Clancy case: A timeline of postpartum struggles, killings and a triple-murder mistrial

By Emily Carter|Business & Economy Reporter
•
Lindsay Clancy case: A timeline of postpartum struggles, killings and a triple-murder mistrial

DUXBURY, Mass. — The case of Lindsay Clancy began in a quiet Boston suburb with insomnia and anxiety after the birth of her third child. It reached a Plymouth courtroom, where a jury could not agree whether the Massachusetts mother was a calculating killer or a woman in the grip of postpartum psychosis.

Clancy’s triple-murder trial ended in a hung jury and a mistrial in early September. Prosecutors argued she intentionally and deliberately strangled her three children. Her defense argued she was suffering from postpartum psychosis at the time and was not criminally responsible for her actions. The competing accounts raised hard questions about maternal mental health, the so-called insanity defense and how juries resolve cases where intent and illness are both central.

Prosecutors have not said whether they will retry her. The next court hearing is set for November 2.

Based on court documents, interviews and trial proceedings, here is a closer look at Clancy’s spiraling mental health, the killings of her children, her trial and her ongoing legal situation.

May 2022: Clancy, a labor and delivery nurse, gives birth to her third child. She lives in Duxbury with her husband, Patrick, and their three young children, Cora, Dawson and Callan.

Lindsay and Patrick Clancy are seen with their children in a photo shown in court on July 27, 2026. Credit: Pool

September 2022: Clancy meets over telehealth with psychiatrist Dr. Jennifer Tufts to address anxiety, depression and insomnia. She is prescribed about a dozen medications and meets with several other providers over the next four months as her mental health declines.

December 31, 2022: Clancy is admitted to McLean Hospital, a psychiatric facility, after reporting thoughts of suicide and intrusive thoughts of hurting her children. She is released after five days to attend her daughter’s birthday party.

January 23, 2023: Clancy tells Tufts she is “doing all right,” denies any suicidal or homicidal ideation and shows no signs of psychosis, according to Tufts.

Lindsay Clancy lived in this home in Duxbury, Massachusetts, with her husband and three children. Credit: Rodrique Ngowi/AP

January 24, 2023: Clancy sends Patrick out of the house to pick up dinner and medication from CVS. While he is gone, she fatally strangles her three children with exercise bands in the basement, cuts her own wrists and neck and jumps out of a second-floor window, according to trial testimony. Patrick returns home to the scene and calls 911.

January 26: Clancy, partially paralyzed and unable to speak, writes on a piece of paper that she is “horrified” and asks for an attorney, according to a hospital psychiatrist.

Late January and early February: Clancy tells her husband and a hospital chaplain she heard a persistent male voice directing her to kill her children and herself.

From left, Callan, Dawson and Cora Clancy. Credit: Pool

February 7: From her hospital bed, Clancy is arraigned on murder charges and pleads not guilty.

September 15, 2023: Clancy is indicted in Plymouth County on three counts of murder.

October 2024: Patrick Clancy speaks publicly to The New Yorker about the killings and expresses empathy for his wife. “I wasn’t married to a monster — I was married to someone who got sick,” he said.

January 2026: Lindsay Clancy files a lawsuit against her medical providers, saying she strangled her children after hearing a voice in her head. “I lost all control. My body started acting without any control on my part,” she wrote in the suit.

July 20, 2026: Clancy’s murder trial begins with jury selection in Plymouth, Massachusetts.

July 26: In opening statements, prosecutors say Clancy “acted intentionally, rationally and swiftly” when she killed her children, while the defense says she was suffering from postpartum psychosis at the time. Patrick Clancy, now divorced from Lindsay, testifies as the trial’s first witness.

Patrick Clancy was sworn in and testified at Lindsay Clancy’s murder trial in July 2026. Credit: David L. Ryan/Pool/Boston Globe

August 17: The prosecution rests its case after calling more than 70 witnesses, including Clancy’s family and friends, first responders, investigators and medical providers.

August 20: More than 100 people wearing pink demonstrate outside Plymouth Superior Court in support of Clancy and to raise awareness for maternal mental healthcare.

August 21: Clancy’s defense rests after calling 10 witnesses, including psychiatric experts who said Clancy suffered from postpartum psychosis.

August 26: The prosecution rests its rebuttal case after calling three mental health experts who said Clancy was not psychotic at the time of the killings.

August 27: Prosecutors and the defense present closing arguments, and the jury begins deliberations.

September 1: On its fourth day of deliberations, the jury reports it is “unable to come to a unanimous decision.” The judge directs the jury to continue deliberating. Outside court, a 56-year-old woman is arrested for allegedly filming jurors leaving the courthouse. She later pleads not guilty.

September 3: A jury note to the court indicates the jury is split 11 to 1 and says the holdout “refuses to listen to the law” on reasonable doubt, according to defense attorney Kevin Reddington. After a heated discussion with Reddington, Judge William Sullivan asks each juror individually whether they can follow his instructions on the law, and each says they can.

Defense attorney Kevin Reddington talks with Lindsay Clancy after a jury question on September 3, 2026. Credit: Greg Derr/Pool/The Patriot Ledger

September 4: Jury notes to the court indicate the jury cannot reach a unanimous verdict because of a single holdout juror. Clancy’s defense files an emergency appeal to further question the holdout juror, but the appeal is denied. Judge Sullivan declares a mistrial due to the deadlocked jury, ending the trial without a clear resolution. Plymouth County District Attorney Timothy Cruz says the prosecution will decide “shortly” whether to retry the case. Reddington says the defense won the case and criticizes the holdout juror.

September 8, 2026: Three jurors tell NBC10 Boston that a single male juror “admitted he had reasonable doubt” but still declined to find her not guilty by reason of insanity.

September 9: Reddington expresses openness to a plea deal in an interview with CNN’s Anderson Cooper.

September 17: The holdout juror issues a statement saying he believed the evidence pointed to a guilty verdict. “I didn’t have any doubts,” he says.

September 20: Patrick Clancy and his new wife, Dr. Rachel Danis, speak to “60 Minutes” about his late children, the trial and whether he feels anger at himself. “I think I did the best I could with what I had at the time, and I live with the outcome,” he says.

September 29: At a court hearing, Clancy’s defense argues prosecutors did not provide sufficient evidence that she killed her children. “Where is the evidence that she did this?” Reddington says. The prosecution calls the argument “laughable.”

October 1: Judge Sullivan denies Clancy’s motion, finding prosecutors presented sufficient trial evidence for a reasonable juror to convict her of murder. Sullivan is still considering other defense motions. He sets a follow-up hearing for November 2.

CNN’s Nicki Brown and Lauren del Valle contributed to this report.

For more CNN news and newsletters, create an account at CNN.com.

Share

This Post Has 0 Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!

Leave a Reply