Long Island Financial Advisor Sentenced to Six Years in Prison for Swindling California Couple Out of Over $1 Million

Original reporting by WealthManagement. Subscribe to our free daily WealthManagement newsletters for more.

A Long Island financial advisor has been sentenced to 72 months in federal prison for defrauding a retired California couple out of more than $1 million, a case that highlights the vulnerabilities investors can face even with seemingly established professionals.

Jeffrey Slothower, 52, was convicted on charges of wire fraud, investment advisor fraud, and money laundering. In addition to the prison term, a federal judge ordered him to pay over $1.16 million in restitution and forfeiture.

"Jeffrey Slothower abused his position of trust to steal over a million dollars from an unsuspecting couple," stated U.S. Attorney Joseph Nocella. FBI Assistant Director James Barnacle added that Slothower constructed "an elaborate facade of profitable returns" to siphon client money for "personal extravagances and to pay down his own substantial debts."

According to court documents, Slothower, who was operating his own firm, Battery Private, in 2017, approached former clients—a couple from California—with a promise of market-beating returns without risk. He persuaded them to invest in what he falsely described as bonds backed by homeowner's association fees, guaranteeing an 8% return.

The victims transferred over $500,000 initially. Instead of investing the funds, Slothower diverted the money to purchase a $125,000 Mercedes-Benz SUV and pay for membership dues at the exclusive Long Island National Golf Club. To maintain the illusion of a successful investment, he fabricated quarterly distribution statements, which convinced the victims—and later the spouse—to contribute additional funds.

Subsequent transfers were used to fund Slothower's lavish personal expenses, including tens of thousands in credit card bills for luxury items from Chanel, Rolex, and Ralph Lauren. The scheme unraveled when the false returns could no longer be sustained.

Compounding the fraud, Slothower also committed mortgage fraud by lying to a lender during a refinancing attempt. He claimed that large deposits from the victims were proceeds from the sale of a personal wine collection, stamps, and fine art, even presenting forged invoices as proof.

Slothower's career included registrations at Goldman Sachs, Northwestern Mutual, and Merrill Lynch before he launched his own advisory. Battery Private terminated its SEC registration in 2017, the same year FINRA suspended Slothower. The SEC filed civil charges in 2021.

Reactions & Analysis

Michael Thorne, Certified Financial Planner in San Diego: "This case is a stark reminder that a prestigious resume is no substitute for rigorous due diligence. Investors must verify credentials independently and be deeply skeptical of any 'guaranteed' returns, especially from individuals operating outside the umbrella of a large, established firm."

David Chen, Former SEC Investigator: "The sentence reflects the severity of a breach of fiduciary duty combined with the audacity of the mortgage fraud. It sends a clear message, but the regulatory gaps that allow advisors with troubled histories to operate solo firms need addressing."

Lisa Gould, Consumer Advocate & Fraud Victim Advocate: "Six years? That's a slap on the wrist! He destroyed a couple's retirement security to buy handbags and golf memberships. The financial and emotional devastation he caused will last far longer than his prison term. The system still favors the perpetrator over the victim."

Robert Hayes, Editor, 'Financial Ethics Quarterly': "Beyond the criminal acts, this underscores a cultural problem in segments of finance where lifestyle inflation and personal debt can become powerful motivators for fraud. The pressure to maintain an image of success can corrupt even those who started with legitimate intentions."