NYISO Report Warns: Surging Natural Gas Prices to Drive Up State Electricity Bills for Years to Come
ROCHESTER, N.Y. — As winter tightens its grip, New Yorkers bracing for higher heating costs now face a prolonged squeeze on their electricity bills, according to a stark assessment from the state's grid operator. A newly released white paper from the New York Independent System Operator (NYISO) concludes that the volatility of the natural gas market is a primary driver behind climbing power prices, a trend with no clear end in sight.
The report details a direct correlation: natural gas fuels approximately 50% of New York's electricity generation. Consequently, fluctuations in gas prices are felt almost immediately by consumers. While wholesale electricity prices saw a temporary dip during the COVID-19 pandemic, they skyrocketed from an average of $25.70 per megawatt-hour (MWh) in 2020 to $89.23/MWh in 2022, largely mirroring global gas market upheavals.
Analysts point to a confluence of factors sustaining the upward pressure. The 2022 invasion of Ukraine disrupted global energy flows, leading Europe to seek alternatives to Russian gas, with U.S. liquefied natural gas (LNG) becoming a key replacement. This surge in international demand has incentivized U.S. exporters to sell abroad, where prices are often higher, reducing domestic supply and lifting home-market costs. NYISO notes LNG export levels in 2026 are projected to be 33% higher than 2024 figures.
Compounding the issue is a tightening supply margin. Since 2019, retirement of older power plants has outpaced the addition of new capacity by nearly two to one (4,315 MW retired vs. 2,274 MW added). Meanwhile, demand is projected to grow by 1,900 MW within the next decade, with an additional 2,500 MW of new demand expected from data centers and semiconductor manufacturers by 2035.
"The grid is experiencing an unprecedented transition and, along with it, unexpected challenges," said Shaun Johnson, NYISO's Vice President of Market Structures. "A variety of complex and evolving factors are impacting the prices that consumers are seeing on their bills."
The NYISO forecasts that natural gas will remain the dominant generation fuel for the foreseeable future, and with demand rising both domestically and internationally, prices are predicted to climb steadily. The U.S. Energy Information Administration had previously estimated natural gas prices for this past winter would be about 22% higher than the winter prior.
Reader Reaction:
Michael Torres, a small business owner from Buffalo: "This isn't just a winter problem anymore; it's a year-round strain. My restaurant's utility costs have doubled since 2020. We're told to electrify everything for climate goals, but if the power source itself is getting more expensive and unstable, what's the real plan?"
Dr. Elena Sharma, Energy Policy Analyst at Cornell University: "The NYISO report underscores a critical vulnerability in our energy system. Our dependence on a globally traded commodity for baseload power creates inherent price risk. This should accelerate investments in demand-side management, storage, and diversifying our in-state generation mix with renewables and firm zero-carbon resources."
David K. Miller, retired engineer from Long Island: "It's pure mismanagement and greed. We're sitting on massive natural gas reserves, yet we're exporting it and forcing families to choose between heating and eating. Our politicians and regulators have failed to ensure energy affordability. This report is just a fancy excuse note for their failure."
Rebecca Chen, a homeowner in Westchester County: "We installed solar panels last year, and this news makes me even more grateful we did. It's a significant upfront cost, but with predictions like these, it feels like the only way to gain some control and predictability over our energy future."
The NYISO's full white paper, "Costs Behind Rising Electricity Prices," is available for download on their official website.
Copyright 2026 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
For the latest news, weather, sports, and streaming video, head to RochesterFirst.