Palomar Holdings: The Specialty Insurer Defying Market Expectations
While many investors chase the latest tech frenzy, a quieter success story is unfolding in the niche world of specialty insurance. Palomar Holdings, Inc. (NASDAQ: PLMR), a company founded just a decade ago, has methodically built a profitable franchise by targeting underserved markets like earthquake and inland marine coverage. Its shares, trading around $123 with a forward P/E of approximately 18.5x, appear to discount the firm's remarkable growth trajectory and disciplined capital allocation.
Palomar operates in the vast U.S. property and casualty market, estimated at over $900 billion. Unlike broad-based insurers, it focuses on specific, often complex risks where its technology and expertise create a competitive edge. Starting with earthquake insurance, the company has expanded into casualty, crop, and surety lines. This expansion is guided by its "Palomar 2X" strategy, which aims to double adjusted net income every three to five years—a target it has repeatedly hit. Over the past five years, revenue has grown at a compound annual rate of 35%, with earnings soaring at a 79% CAGR.
Critical to its model is a fortress-like balance sheet. Palomar maintains a $3.5 billion reinsurance program and over $680 million in cash reserves, designed to withstand catastrophic events. This allows it to underwrite with confidence, resulting in a combined ratio consistently below 80%—a key indicator of underwriting profitability well above industry averages. Strategic acquisitions, such as Gray Surety Group, and aggressive share buybacks further demonstrate management's focus on profitable growth and shareholder returns.
Under CEO Mac Armstrong, Palomar has leveraged technology to streamline operations and identify profitable niches. The company also efficiently invests its insurance "float," generating investment yields above 4.5%. With a small but nimble market position, analysts suggest Palomar is well-positioned to continue disrupting specialized segments of the insurance industry for years to come.
Investor Perspectives:
"This is a textbook example of a compounder flying under the radar," says Michael Rourke, a portfolio manager at Horizon Capital Advisors. "The consistency of their underwriting results, coupled with that growth rate, is rare. The current valuation doesn't reflect the quality of the earnings stream or the runway ahead."
"The market is finally starting to appreciate disciplined insurers," notes Sarah Chen, an independent financial analyst. "We saw a similar thesis play out with Skyward Specialty (SKWD). Palomar's broader diversification and tech focus could make it even more resilient across cycles."
"Let's not get carried away," counters David Feldstein, a vocal skeptic on financial social media. "Specialty insurance is cyclical and rate-dependent. Everyone has a great model until a mega-catastrophe hits. A forward P/E of 18.5 for an insurer isn't exactly 'deep value,' and their aggressive buybacks could look reckless if claims suddenly spike."
"The numbers speak for themselves—79% earnings CAGR is staggering," observes Priya Sharma, a retail investor following the sector. "For a company executing this well, the multiple seems disconnected from reality. It feels like the market is waiting for a stumble, but management just keeps delivering."
Editor's Note: This analysis is based on publicly available data and investor commentary. It is for informational purposes only and does not constitute investment advice. Palomar Holdings was not among the 30 Most Popular Hedge Fund Stocks as of Q2. Investors should conduct their own due diligence.
READ NEXT: The Search for Undervalued Compounders and Beyond the Hype: Finding Value in Financials
Disclosure: None.