Permanent Daylight Saving Time Could Make School Mornings Riskier for Children, Study Finds

By Sophia Reynolds|Financial Markets Editor
•
Permanent Daylight Saving Time Could Make School Mornings Riskier for Children, Study Finds

Most Americans will turn their clocks back one hour on Sunday, Nov. 1, ending daylight saving time for another year. But as the twice-yearly ritual returns, a new study is drawing attention to a question with real safety stakes: What would happen if the country stopped changing its clocks and stayed on daylight saving time all year?

The research, published Thursday in the journal Current Biology, suggests that permanent daylight saving time could push millions of school commutes into darkness—and raise the risk that children are struck by vehicles.

Scientists at the University of Washington examined start times at more than 16,000 schools in 14 states, covering roughly 8.6 million children. They compared three scenarios: permanent standard time, the current system of switching clocks twice a year, and permanent daylight saving time.

Under permanent daylight saving time, the study estimated there would be about 356 million additional school commutes before sunrise each year in those 14 states compared with the current system. Expanded nationwide, the authors projected more than 2 billion additional dark-morning school commutes annually.

To put the findings in context and offer practical advice for families, CNN turned to wellness expert Dr. Leana Wen. Wen is an emergency physician and clinical associate professor at George Washington University, a former Baltimore health commissioner and the mother of two young children.

What happens when the clocks fall back?

CNN: Can you explain what happens when daylight saving time ends on November 1, and why we change clocks twice a year?

Dr. Leana Wen: At 2 a.m. Sunday, clocks will fall back to 1 a.m. By our clocks, sunrise and sunset will arrive an hour earlier. In practical terms, people will get more daylight in the morning, but darkness will come earlier in the evening.

Daylight saving time was adopted to shift more daylight into the evening during warmer months. In the United States, it currently runs from the second Sunday in March to the first Sunday in November.

The twice-yearly changes remain controversial because they disrupt sleep schedules and daily routines. The spring transition is especially hard because people lose an hour of sleep. The fall transition gives us an extra hour, but it can still unsettle sleep, particularly for young children who have established bedtime and wake-up routines.

The case for and against permanent daylight saving time

CNN: There have been proposals to make daylight saving time permanent. Why do some people support that?

Wen: The main argument is convenience: people would no longer have to change their clocks twice a year. Supporters also favor more evening daylight throughout the year, which could give people who finish work or school in the late afternoon more time for outdoor exercise and recreation. Extra evening light could benefit some businesses and may reduce some traffic accidents.

The Sunshine Protection Act, which the U.S. House of Representatives passed in July, proposes making daylight saving time permanent nationwide. If enacted, Americans would stay on daylight saving time through the winter. That would mean an extra hour of evening daylight, but sunrise would also come an hour later during the winter months.

Not everyone supports that approach. Some advocates of ending clock changes prefer permanent standard time, which would keep the country on winter time year-round and stop the switch to daylight saving time altogether.

What the study found about dark school commutes

CNN: What did this new study find about the potential risks to children traveling to school?

Wen: The team calculated how many school mornings children would have to leave home before sunrise under three scenarios: permanent standard time, the current system of changing clocks twice a year, and permanent daylight saving time.

The authors estimated that permanent daylight saving time would result in approximately 356 million additional school commutes before sunrise each year in those 14 states, compared with the current system. When researchers extended their analysis nationwide, they estimated more than 2 billion additional dark-morning school commutes annually.

The researchers then examined whether traveling in darkness could pose additional safety risks. They analyzed nationwide fatal motor vehicle crashes from 2015 through 2024, focusing on more than 10,000 fatal crashes that occurred on school-year mornings between 7 and 8:30 a.m.

They found that crashes before sunrise had 77% higher odds of involving a pedestrian than crashes after sunrise. When the researchers focused specifically on children ages 5 to 18, the odds of pedestrian involvement were more than twice as high during dark mornings. That suggests schoolchildren could face greater risks if daylight saving time became permanent.

The United States briefly adopted permanent daylight saving time during the energy crisis in 1974 but reversed course within months, partly because of concerns about children traveling to school in the dark.

Why children face special risks in the dark

CNN: Why are children particularly vulnerable to traffic accidents during dark mornings?

Wen: Visibility is a major factor. Drivers have more difficulty seeing pedestrians in the dark, especially children, who tend to be smaller and less visible. Children crossing streets to walk to school or reach a bus stop may be exposed to greater risk.

Younger children are also still developing the ability to judge vehicle speed and distance. They may be less predictable when crossing streets. Teenagers who drive to school also face risks associated with limited driving experience.

Despite the significance of the findings, policymakers should keep the study’s limitations in mind. This was not an experiment in which researchers changed clock policies and measured subsequent crashes. Instead, they used existing school schedules, sunrise calculations and historical crash records to estimate potential effects. The nationwide estimate also relied on an assumed school start time of 8 a.m., which is not the case everywhere. In fact, many schools start later.

Even so, I think the findings identify a plausible safety concern. As the researchers pointed out, children from lower-income families could be disproportionately affected because some must travel early to participate in school breakfast programs and are more likely to rely on walking and public transportation.

Weighing permanent daylight saving time against permanent standard time

CNN: What are the arguments for and against making daylight saving time permanent? Is permanent standard time a better alternative?

Wen: Permanent daylight saving time would provide more evening daylight, which many people value. Some research has also suggested that it could reduce vehicle collisions with deer. On the other hand, permanent standard time would preserve more daylight in the morning, when children and commuters are traveling to school and work.

Several medical organizations, including sleep medicine specialists, favor permanent standard time because it better aligns our schedules with our natural biological clocks, known as circadian rhythms. These internal clocks regulate sleep, alertness and other physiological functions. Morning sunlight helps synchronize them and signals to the brain that it is time to be awake.

None of these proposals, of course, would actually protect sunlight or add more daylight to the day. The question for policymakers is when that daylight would occur and how best to balance the benefits of morning versus evening light.

How families can prepare for the time change

CNN: In the meantime, we are still changing clocks soon. How can parents and guardians prepare their children—and themselves—in the days leading up to the time change?

Wen: For people with younger children, or for anyone who has had trouble with time changes in the past, I recommend making small adjustments several days before the transition.

Because clocks are moving backward, a child who normally goes to bed at 8 p.m. will feel ready for bed at 7 p.m. after the change. Parents can gradually shift bedtime later by about 15 minutes every day for four days before November 1. Moving meals, bath time and other evening routines later can help reinforce the adjustment.

Try to maintain consistent wake-up times, and expose children right away to natural light in the morning. Outdoor activity in the morning and throughout the day also supports healthy sleep. In the evening, keep a predictable wind-down routine and try not to offer screens before bedtime.

Adults can use similar strategies. Some people may feel sleepy earlier in the evening or wake up earlier than intended. Others may experience an afternoon slump because it gets dark earlier. I would recommend taking a walk outdoors during daylight hours, exercising regularly and avoiding caffeine late in the day.

Families should also prepare for earlier sunsets. Children who walk or bike home from school or participate in afternoon activities may find themselves traveling in darkness sooner than before. Kids should wear reflective clothing, use lights on bicycles, use marked crossings, and ideally travel with an adult or a group of friends to improve visibility and safety.

Sign up for CNN’s Life, But Better newsletter for information and tools designed to improve your well-being. For more CNN news and newsletters, create an account at CNN.com.

Share

This Post Has 0 Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!

Leave a Reply