Second sexual assault allegation in a month jolts University of Chicago-area fraternity scene

Editor’s note: Help is available. For help in the US, call the National Sexual Assault Hotline at 1-800-656-4673 or chat 24/7 at online.rainn.org.
Two women have alleged this month that they were sexually assaulted at separate fraternity houses near the University of Chicago, adding to a wave of allegations that is putting universities under renewed pressure over how they handle sexual misconduct in their communities.
The most recent report involves a 21-year-old woman who told the university she was sexually assaulted at a nearby fraternity house on Oct. 11. The university said last week that a person of interest had been identified and banned from campus, and Chicago police are investigating. No arrests have been reported.
The other allegation surfaced in a lawsuit filed Monday by a 19-year-old college student using the pseudonym Jane Doe. She alleges she was sexually assaulted by a fraternity member at an Alpha Delta Phi party in February. The suit names Alpha Delta Phi Inc. and the Chicago Society of Alpha Delta Phi as defendants. The University of Chicago is not named as a defendant but is listed as a respondent in discovery, an Illinois procedure that allows Doe to seek information from the school and potentially add it as a defendant if evidence warrants.
Doe does not attend the University of Chicago, her attorney Georgia Booth told CNN affiliate WLS. CNN obtained the lawsuit from The Chicago Maroon, the university’s student newspaper, which first reported on it.
University of Chicago spokesperson Gerald McSwiggan told CNN the allegations are very disturbing to the campus community. He noted the school is not named as a defendant in the lawsuit but said it is committed to addressing and preventing incidents of sexual assault. The university has previously said fraternities are not formally affiliated with the University of Chicago, though student members are subject to university policies and disciplinary procedures.
According to the lawsuit, Doe attended a party at the Alpha Delta Phi house and accepted a shot of unidentified alcohol from a fraternity brother that quickly made her feel unsteady and lightheaded. The fraternity brother then led her to a secluded bedroom on another floor, where he allegedly made unwanted and nonconsensual sexual advances after she lost all physical and verbal ability to refuse him. The suit alleges Doe was mentally and physically incapable of providing consent.
Doe pleaded with the man to use a condom, but he refused, according to the complaint. The lawsuit says the fraternity brother then penetrated her without her consent and left her alone and unconscious in the room. Doe’s friend was initially blocked by other fraternity brothers from going upstairs to check on her until a member who saw Doe unconscious told them to let the friend up, the suit says. The friend found Doe unconscious and helped her out of the house.
The next morning, Doe found bloodstains in her underwear, reported the incident to the Chicago Police Department and named the fraternity brother who allegedly assaulted her, according to the lawsuit. Chicago police told CNN a 19-year-old woman said she was sexually assaulted around 1 a.m. Feb. 8 inside a residence on the 5700 block of South University Avenue and later went to a hospital. Police did not name the fraternity, but Doe told officers she was assaulted at the fraternity’s address on that same block, according to the lawsuit. The incident, now more than eight months old, remains under investigation.
Alpha Delta Phi said it suspended the member involved after learning of the allegations. In a statement, the fraternity called the conduct described deeply troubling and inconsistent with its values. It said it would cooperate with law enforcement as appropriate but could not discuss specifics because of the active lawsuit. Doe’s suit claims the fraternity failed to abide by its own rules of conduct, including providing sober monitors at events and protecting against sexual assault by its members. The lawsuit seeks more than $50,000 on each of four counts, citing Doe’s severe and permanent psychological and emotional distress and other harms.
The October allegation has drawn attention in part because a confrontation was captured on camera. A video shows a woman chasing a man through the streets of Chicago whom she believed had sexually assaulted her friend at a fraternity party. The alleged incident was reported last weekend at a fraternity house and is under investigation by the university and the Chicago Police Department.
No suspects are in custody and police have not made any arrests, but the university said a person of interest has been identified. The man is not a University of Chicago student and has been banned from campus, the university said. Mia Lara, the woman seen in the confrontation video, told CNN her friend had previously rejected a man’s advances to go upstairs at the fraternity party that night. She eventually discovered her friend was with the man in a bathroom while Lara said she saw the man’s friends banging on the door, cheering and saying they wanted to get in.
Lara found her friend slumped on the bathroom floor, partially clothed, saying get me out of here and that she did not want to be there, Lara said. She added she had never seen her friend in that state before. After helping her friend leave the fraternity house, Lara said her friends went to sit on the sidewalk and noticed the same group of men pointing and laughing at the woman who said she was assaulted. Lara said she pointed at the man and asked what he had done to her friend.
In a video that was widely viewed and shared online, Lara follows a man while yelling at the camera that he had assaulted her friend in the bathroom of a fraternity party and that he could record as much as he wanted. CNN has reached out to Chicago police and the University of Chicago for comment about the video.
On Wednesday, members of the university’s Public Safety Advisory Council, which is separate from the administration, addressed sexual misconduct support and education in a meeting. They declined to address the specific incidents but stressed that safeguards are in place on campus to protect students. University of Chicago Police Chief Kyle Bowman said the top priority is preventing people from becoming victims.
Bowman said the first step is to tell men not to commit sexual assault and to respect the people they are with. He said the campus community has a mutual understanding that it is an academic environment where people are learning, creating an expectation consistent with the code of conduct. The chief added that the university has an app students can use to request assistance from campus police if they do not feel safe. According to the university, Wednesday’s meeting had already been scheduled before the sexual assault allegations became public, as part of a regular series of public safety meetings.
The allegations come as universities face heightened scrutiny after an alleged gang rape at a Cornell University fraternity house spurred a nationwide debate over how schools handle sexual assault claims. At the University of Arizona, a sorority member told campus police she was sexually assaulted by two men at a fraternity house in late August, according to search warrant records cited by The Associated Press.
CNN’s Cindy Von Quednow and Bill Kirkos contributed to this report. For more CNN news and newsletters, create an account at CNN.com.
