Texas Appeals Court Rejects Stay for Jamaal Howard After Christa Pike’s Failed Lethal Injection

A Texas appeals court on Wednesday declined to stop the scheduled execution of Jamaal Howard, a man convicted of killing a convenience store clerk, after his defense team pointed to Christa Pike’s failed lethal injection in Tennessee as evidence of the risks posed by the state’s execution drug.
Howard’s execution, set for later Wednesday, would be the first in the United States since Pike survived an attempted execution last week. Like Pike, Howard, 46, was scheduled to receive pentobarbital. His attorneys told the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals that the drug presents the same potential problems and also questioned the quality of Texas’ execution drugs.
The court denied the stay request without explanation. Howard’s attorneys then filed a second request seeking to halt the execution over the drug; the court did not immediately respond.
Pike, 50, survived two doses of pentobarbital on Sept. 30. She was hospitalized and, by Wednesday, was awake and speaking, her lawyers said. Her legal team is seeking more information about what went wrong. “Texas should not be eager to follow in Tennessee’s footsteps; a stay would keep that from happening,” Howard’s attorneys argued.
Texas has carried out six executions this year. Two more are scheduled after Howard, who would become the 30th person executed nationwide in 2026, the filing says. The case is unfolding amid heightened scrutiny of lethal injection protocols, particularly in states that rely on pentobarbital, a barbiturate that has become a central part of execution procedures as pharmaceutical companies have restricted access to other drugs. When an execution does not go as planned, it can intensify legal challenges and raise questions about whether states are prepared to handle complications. The dispute also underscores how a failed execution in one state can quickly shape legal arguments in another, especially when the same drug is involved.
Howard was found guilty of capital murder in the 2000 killing of Vickie Swartout, 42. Prosecutors said Swartout was shot once in the chest during a robbery. Jurors saw surveillance video from the store showing Howard shooting her, according to court records.
Howard was 20 at the time. He took $114 and a carton of cigarettes from the store in Silsbee, a small rural town about 100 miles northeast of Houston, court records show.
His attorneys have argued that Howard is intellectually disabled and should not be executed. The state has said he has not presented evidence showing he meets the legal requirements for an intellectual disability claim. Howard also has a pending appeal before the U.S. Supreme Court seeking to stop the execution. The Supreme Court barred the execution of intellectually disabled people in 2002, but it has left states some discretion in deciding how such disabilities are determined.
In the motion filed early Wednesday in the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals, Howard’s attorneys said they had asked for information about the lethal dose of pentobarbital the Texas Department of Criminal Justice planned to use. They said the department sought a state attorney general’s opinion on whether it had to disclose that information, despite what they described as a years-long practice of releasing it. The attorney general’s opinion is not expected before Wednesday ends, according to the defense, leaving Howard unable to litigate whatever decision the state makes about disclosure.
Texas officials did not immediately respond to a request for comment Wednesday morning. Nationally, Florida has carried out 16 executions this year, the most of any state. Most states that allow executions use lethal injection as their primary method. In Tennessee, Republican Gov. Bill Lee has halted the one remaining execution scheduled for the rest of the year.
For more CNN news and newsletters, create an account at CNN.com.
