Texas Court Denies Stay for Jamaal Howard as Attorneys Cite Pike's Botched Execution

The Texas Court of Criminal Appeals on Wednesday refused to halt the scheduled execution of Jamaal Howard, rejecting an 11th-hour request from attorneys who argued that the pentobarbital Texas planned to use carried risks similar to those exposed in Christa Pike's failed lethal injection in Tennessee.
Howard, 46, was set to be put to death later Wednesday. It would be the first U.S. execution since Pike, 50, survived two doses of pentobarbital last week—an outcome that has renewed scrutiny of lethal injection protocols and the drugs states use to carry them out.
The court denied the stay without explaining its decision. Howard's attorneys quickly filed a second request to stop the execution over the drug, but there was no immediate response. Texas officials did not immediately return a request for comment Wednesday morning.
“Texas should not be eager to follow in Tennessee's footsteps; a stay would keep that from happening,” Howard's attorneys argued in their filing.
At issue is pentobarbital, the same barbiturate used in Pike's attempted execution. Howard's attorneys told the Court of Criminal Appeals that the drug poses similar risks in Texas, and they questioned the quality and age of the state's execution drugs. They also said they had sought information about the lethal dose the Texas Department of Criminal Justice planned to use. The department asked for a state attorney general's opinion on whether it had to disclose that information, they said, despite what they described as a years-long practice of doing so.
Because the attorney general's opinion is not expected before Thursday, Howard cannot litigate whatever decision the state makes on releasing the information in time to affect Wednesday's scheduled execution, his attorneys argued.
Pike's case has intensified those concerns. After surviving two doses of pentobarbital, she was hospitalized and, as of Tuesday, was awake and speaking. Her attorneys said she was “conscious, speaking, and continues to receive critical medical care,” but added that “her prognosis remains unclear” and that they expect “at a minimum ... a long recovery.”
They also said that despite severe damage to her arms, Pike remained handcuffed and shackled to her bed. One of her attorneys, Steve Ferrell, told “CBS Mornings” on Monday that doctors were working to clear the drug from her body and that she was on a ventilator.
Pike's lawyers have alleged that her execution was complicated by blown veins, deteriorated pentobarbital and a lack of emergency medical care. They are seeking more information about what went wrong. Howard's attorneys pointed to those allegations in arguing that Texas's drugs may also be degraded, saying they are far past the beyond-use dates allowed by the U.S. Pharmacopeia for drugs of that kind. “There is a similar risk,” they wrote.
The legal scramble in Texas underscored how quickly Pike's case has become a reference point in other capital cases, particularly as states confront aging drug supplies, supplier secrecy and questions about whether executions can be carried out without prolonged suffering.
Howard was convicted of capital murder in the 2000 killing of Vickie Swartout, 42, a convenience store clerk. Swartout was shot once in the chest during a robbery in Silsbee, a small rural town about 100 miles northeast of Houston. Trial evidence included store surveillance video showing Howard shooting her, according to court records.
Howard, who was 20 at the time, took $114 and a carton of cigarettes from the store, records show. He is now 46.
His attorneys have argued that Howard is intellectually disabled and that his execution should be halted. The state has said he has not presented evidence showing he meets the requirements for such a claim. A separate appeal to the U.S. Supreme Court is pending. In 2002, the Supreme Court barred the execution of intellectually disabled people but gave states some discretion in determining who qualifies.
Texas has carried out six executions so far this year, with two more scheduled after Howard, whose execution would be the 30th nationwide in 2026. The state remains a leading execution state, though Florida has performed 16 executions this year, the most of any state. Most death penalty states use lethal injection as their primary method.
Tennessee's Republican Gov. Bill Lee has halted the one remaining execution in his state for the rest of the year, a move that followed Pike's failed execution.
Separately, an execution date has been set for Dec. 3 for former Army Maj. Nidal Hasan, who killed 13 people in a 2009 shooting at Fort Hood. According to an email sent to victims' families, Hasan will be executed at the same post where he carried out the attack. He is set to die by firing squad in what would be the first military execution since 1961.
Pentagon spokesman Sean Parnell said late Monday that the plan to use an Army firing squad was recommended by Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth and approved by President Trump.
