Under Watch in Wartime Moscow: Western Envoys Describe Surveillance and ‘Constant Paranoia’

Moscow — For Western diplomats assigned to Russia, the job has become a test of endurance in a country that regards their governments as hostile. Five envoys who have served in Moscow since Russia launched its full-scale invasion of Ukraine told the BBC that the pressures now feel closer to the Cold War than to the post-Soviet diplomatic routine they once knew: constant surveillance, isolation, staffing shortages and a pervasive sense that little can be controlled, as the war in Ukraine grinds into its fifth year.
Lynne Tracy, who represented the United States in Moscow from 2023 until 2025, described the posting as the hardest of her career. Her 30-year career included Pakistan, where she survived an armed attack in 2008. Even in Peshawar, she said, she felt more of her work was within her control. In Moscow, the defining difficulty was uncertainty, driven largely by unrelenting Russian counterintelligence pressure.
The comparison to the Cold War is not rhetorical. Former Western diplomats describe physical surveillance, listening devices hidden in gifts and even the use of “spy dust,” a near-invisible chemical agent once used to track officials. A former European diplomat said the warning before arriving in Moscow was blunt: expect listening devices, and expect cameras in every room of your house.
The diplomatic footprint has shrunk sharply since 2022. Hundreds of Russian diplomats were expelled from European countries and the United States after the invasion. Moscow responded in kind, declaring hundreds of Western diplomatspersona non grata and leaving many embassies short-staffed. The result is a smaller, more guarded presence at a moment when communication between Russia and the West is already dangerously thin.
Russian diplomats in the West have complained of unfair treatment, but the diplomats interviewed by the BBC said the scope and tactics of Moscow’s intelligence services are far greater. One former ambassador said he was forced to dismiss two Russian employees after the FSB, Russia’s domestic security service, tried to recruit them and demanded that they report on everything happening at the diplomatic mission. The employees told the embassy instead, and were let go — otherwise, the ambassador said, they could have faced criminal prosecution.
Russians who might ordinarily build relationships with diplomatic staff — in academia, culture and other fields — are being intimidated into avoiding contact with Western officials. One former ambassador said his guests were once followed by FSB agents right up to the embassy doors. In June, guests invited to the British ambassador’s residence in Moscow for King’s birthday celebrations said they were harassed by pro-Kremlin activists and state-media journalists and then questioned by police. One guest said he has since declined several invitations to Western embassy events out of fear.
The strain has driven some officials out. A former ambassador said “constant paranoia” led a number of diplomats to quit, and that even after leaving Russia he spent months looking over his shoulder. Not everyone can absorb that kind of pressure, and embassies have had to adapt both operationally and psychologically.
After the invasion, European governments debated whether to recall ambassadors or stop working in Russia altogether. Former French ambassador Pierre Lévy said he called Paris immediately to argue that pulling envoys would be a mistake. The worse relations became, he felt, the more important it was to keep a diplomatic channel open. Both Tracy and Lévy later attended the funeral of opposition leader Alexei Navalny in March 2024, a moment that underlined the risks and symbolism of diplomatic presence in Putin’s Russia.
Another former European ambassador said the invasion quickly transformed the job. The cooperation needed for normal work on bilateral relations, trade and joint projects was suddenly impossible. For those who stayed, new priorities crowded out the old agenda: maintaining at least some line of communication with Russian officials to understand what was happening inside the country, protecting staff and keeping embassies functioning.
Practical problems mounted. After Russia banned the hiring of foreign nationals in 2021, the U.S. embassy’s facilities team was left significantly understaffed. Even a minor plumbing issue, such as a leaking pipe, could become a major disruption and consume diplomatic time. One diplomat recalled discussing staffing shortages with a Russian official, who advised him not to get too upset. “He said, ‘At least you still have the chef,’” the diplomat recalled.
Western financial sanctions imposed after the invasion created a different set of daily difficulties. Once Russian banks were cut off from the SWIFT payment network and Mastercard and Visa suspended operations in Russia, many embassies struggled to cover basic operating expenses. A former ambassador recalled running out of cash and being unable to pay staff — until another diplomat, who was selling his car after being expelled, brought the rubles to the embassy in a suitcase. “It’s completely insane,” the diplomat said with a laugh. “But you had to look at it with a sense of humor.”
The history of espionage in Moscow is long. In 1945, a wooden replica of the Great Seal of the United States was given to the American ambassador to Russia as a gift; it was later found to contain a listening device. The current era may be less elaborate in its props, but diplomats say the intent is familiar: to monitor, pressure and isolate.
Russian officials make little secret of their attitude. They have openly accused diplomats from “unfriendly countries” of engaging in espionage and have been especially critical of those who show interest in dissent against the Kremlin. According to Russian journalist Alexei Venediktov, Moscow has effectively banned most Russian officials from speaking to Western embassies. He said he has told Russian officials that they are being misunderstood precisely because of their own actions — because ambassadors cannot do their jobs.
One former European ambassador said Moscow now has little to no contact with many Western governments. “There are no calls, no meetings at ministerial level,” the ambassador said. Yet that breakdown has made diplomats more important, not less, leaving them to communicate their governments’ positions to a Kremlin that is increasingly closed off.
“Generals prove what they can do during a war. The same is true for diplomats,” the former ambassador said. “When things get really difficult, every single thing you do actually matters.”
Tracy left Moscow in 2025 believing she had accomplished her primary mission: the U.S. Embassy had held firm. She is also proud of the work she and her team did to maintain connections between Americans and ordinary Russians. “Because at some point, government-to-government relations will have a chance to improve,” she said, “and those ties between people will be there to help speed the improvement.”
For Western governments, the broader lesson is that diplomacy in wartime Russia is no longer a routine assignment. It is a constrained, high-risk form of presence-keeping — one that may shape how quickly, and through what channels, any future thaw can begin. The envoys who remain are operating in a narrow space between surveillance and silence, trying to preserve a line of communication that both sides may need when the war eventually gives way to negotiation.
