Vance says Trump administration must act when ICE agents 'screw up'

Washington — Vice President JD Vance acknowledged that some federal immigration officers "really screw up" and said the Trump administration has a responsibility to act when they do, using a CBS News town hall in Michigan to address growing scrutiny of immigration enforcement.
Vance spoke with "CBS Evening News" anchor Tony Dokoupil for an hourlong town hall that aired Saturday. The Michigan setting put the remarks in a politically sensitive state, where the Senate race between Republican Mike Rogers and Democrat Abdul El-Sayed is among the most closely watched contests in the country and immigration remains a volatile issue.
During an exchange about immigration, Vance drew comparisons between law enforcement officers and members of Immigration and Customs Enforcement, or ICE.
"Most of them are amazing people who are patriots and they wanna do a good job protecting their country. Sometimes you have some people who make mistakes. Sometimes you have some people who really screw up," Vance said. "And obviously, we have a responsibility to prosecute, investigate when people do screw up."
Dokoupil pressed Vance on specific cases, noting that in some instances "people talk about them before they're investigated," and asked him to identify the biggest mistakes involving ICE's immigration actions. Vance declined to single out any incident but said the administration has responded when officers have been accused of misconduct.
"There are a number of cases where we've investigated and either provided further training, or sometimes even provided disciplinary situations within ICE," Vance said. "We don't always advertise that stuff, as you know, Tony, because we believe that people have to be judged in a court of law and through a normal investigatory process."
The comments come as the Trump administration has expanded immigration enforcement as part of President Trump's crackdown, intensifying scrutiny of use-of-force practices by ICE and U.S. Customs and Border Protection. That scrutiny has created a political test for the administration: it must show it is holding officers accountable without undercutting the enforcement agenda Vance and other officials have defended.
Two Americans, Renee Good and Alex Pretti, were shot and killed by immigration authorities during protests in Minnesota earlier this year. The ICE officer who fatally shot Good, Jonathan Ross, was placed on administrative leave shortly after the shooting. In May, New York Gov. Kathy Hochul questioned whether Ross had been reassigned to her state, and the Department of Homeland Security declined at the time to say where he was working.
No criminal charges have been filed in either case, and the Justice Department opened an investigation into Pretti's shooting earlier this year.
There have since been a series of incidents involving immigration officers during targeted enforcement operations. In a case in Maine, an ICE officer fatally shot a 25-year-old Colombian man in his car, and in September, an immigration officer shot a Venezuelan man in the back in Austin, Texas.
Earlier this month, ICE agents shot a man in New York during a targeted enforcement operation, striking him in the neck. The agents were trying to arrest Oscar Belgal, who is from the Dominican Republic, while a 5-year-old boy was in the back seat. Separately, a vehicle driven by ICE agents hit and injured a man near Houston.
The full episode of "Things That Matter: A Town Hall With Vice President JD Vance" is streaming on Paramount+, and it will also be available on YouTube, CBS News 24/7 and CBSNews.com.
