War drew America's southern border, but centuries of culture refused to be erased

By Sophia Reynolds|Financial Markets Editor
•
War drew America's southern border, but centuries of culture refused to be erased

LAS CRUCES, N.M. — Nicholas Natividad's great-great-great grandfather Juan Velarde was born on land that, within a single lifetime, was claimed by four different nations. The territory that is now the desert Southwest bore the flags of Spain, Mexico, the Republic of Texas, briefly the Confederacy (which his family opposed), and finally the United States.

As America marks its 250th anniversary, the U.S.-Mexico border's long migration south is more than a story of maps and treaties. It is the story of a young nation’s insatiable westward expansion — absorbing Native American tribes, Spanish descendants and Mexican citizens — and of the people who, through resilience and quiet resistance, kept their languages, ceremonies and traditions alive.

“With every shift in the border has come a shift in consciousness,” said Natividad, a criminal justice and border studies professor at New Mexico State University in Las Cruces. “The way we relate to food, to the mountains, to the river, to each other.”

Six generations later, Natividad still lives in the Paso del Norte region — a jagged landscape of rugged mountains and high desert valley that turns green where the Rio Grande runs. He speaks Spanish and English, and identifies as Mexican American. His family tree spans southern New Mexico, West Texas, and Mexico — a region where the borderline shifted at least four times in the 19th century and a fifth time in the 20th, tugged south by war, treaty and purchase.

“The trauma that he went through,” Natividad said of his ancestor, “I always wonder if that trauma is deeply embedded within our DNA.”

In the fourth-floor archive of New Mexico State’s Branson Library, Dennis Daily pulls a fragile 19th-century map from its plastic sleeve. The collection includes maps by French, Dutch, Spanish and American cartographers. One black-and-white map, titled in Spanish “Mapa de los Estados Unidos de Méjico,” was published in 1847 by New York mapmaker John Disturnell. Inaccurate as they were, his maps served as the basis for the Treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo, which added 525,000 square miles to U.S. territory in 1848.

“These maps allow us to see how these changes have occurred over time — and to see the people who were here prior to Spain, prior to Mexico, prior to the United States,” said Daily, who oversees the special collections.

For 300 years, Spain claimed the vast region that now includes modern Mexico, Texas, New Mexico, Arizona, Utah, Nevada, Colorado and California. Mexico won its independence in 1821 after an 11-year war. Then Texas fought for its own independence, and for a decade after 1836 the Republic of Texas flew its Lone Star flag over El Paso and parts of southern New Mexico.

In 1845 the United States annexed Texas; war with Mexico erupted the next year. The Treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo, signed in 1848, gave the U.S. a stunning expansion to the Pacific — or, as many on the south side saw it, a stunning theft.

“While being 250 years old as a nation, this region doesn't have the same birth date as the United States,” said Ruben Leyva, a Gila Apache border scholar at New Mexico State. “We look not so much to 1776 as the starting point for modern U.S. identity. We look at the Mexican-American War in 1848.”

That convulsive period — when the Southwest was forced into the United States — remains etched in family memory. On a Sunday afternoon in early May, troupes of dancers in San Elizario, Texas, turned the town plaza into a stage for a reenactment of 500 years of borderlands history. A white adobe chapel, built where a Spanish fort once stood, towered over them.

Tigua dancers of the Ysleta del Sur Pueblo performed a prayerful ceremony traditional before a hunt. Men wore buffalo headdresses and draped otter pelts; women wore flower-print shawls. Other troupes followed in the style of each subsequent power: Spanish flamenco in long black dresses, Mexican ballet folklórico in colorful swooshing skirts, Tejano two-step in jeans and boots.

“I think we're very patriotic, but we stuck to our Mexican roots — like our traditions, our fiestas, our dress, our food, the language,” said Lillian Trujillo, born nearby and raised in San Elizario, speaking in both English and Spanish.

What was not reenacted: the bloodshed that accompanied each transition, nor the quieter efforts to erase culture. Until very recently, children in West Texas public schools were punished — even beaten — for speaking Spanish. Today, bilingual education thrives.

“We can celebrate the founding,” Leyva said, “but at the same time we have to understand … it's a story of violence and removal and captivity and warfare and dispossession as a part of that history.” Borderland people keep that history and cling to identity “like a living legacy,” he added.

San Elizario existed under at least three flags. Founded as a Spanish presidio in the late 1700s, it became part of Mexico after Spain fell. In 1830, a massive flood changed the Rio Grande’s course, placing San Elizario north of the river — and thus part of the United States after the Mexican-American War.

Trujillo, president of the San Elizario Genealogy and Historical Society, spent 10 years organizing the Catholic chapel’s historical records — digitizing 20,000 baptisms, marriages and deaths. The museum on the plaza holds dozens of white binders organized by last name, Alarcón to Zuñiga.

“Whatever they bring us, we put up here,” she said, flipping through a binder. She paused at a familiar sepia-toned photograph of her grandfather in a U.S. Army uniform from World War I. “Like I said, very patriotic.”

At dawn and dusk, the borderland mountains of Paso del Norte form a jagged watercolor line of deep purple on the horizon. These same mountains appear in black-and-white photographs from the 1890s, when the newly created U.S. Boundary Commission sought to document the desert borderline amid concerns that no one knew exactly where it lay. The line was marked by obelisks — 276 of them today — placed roughly within view of one another from El Paso west to the Pacific. Eastward, the Rio Grande itself marks the boundary on its way to the Gulf of America (or Mexico, depending on perspective).

The border last moved in the Paso del Norte region in the 1960s. A small island formed in the Rio Grande between El Paso and Ciudad Juárez sparked a dispute resolved by the Chamizal Convention of 1963. President Lyndon B. Johnson met with Mexico’s Adolfo López Mateos in El Paso the following year to formalize the agreement.

The borderline has been, at turns, ignored to the point of poverty; maligned as “insecure”; barricaded by monuments, border agents, steel bollards and razor wire. In March, U.S. government contractors blasted away the south slope of Mount Cristo Rey — one of the mountains pictured in the 1890s survey — to make way for the border wall.

Rudy Cruz Jr., a member of the Ysleta del Sur Pueblo and mayor of Socorro, Texas, knows his people’s story by heart. How they revolted against the Spanish in 1680 and were captured at the northern Isleta Pueblo near modern-day Albuquerque. How they were forcibly marched 400 miles south. Today, the Tigua are a sovereign nation in Socorro, a rural hamlet between El Paso and San Elizario.

“Have we maintained our ceremonies, traditions and dances? Yes,” Cruz said, “but there is a strong Spanish influence.” Many Tigua are Catholic, he noted, yet they keep a strict separation of church and tradition. The pueblo holds an original ceremonial drum centuries old, brought during the forced march south. “The drum will never enter a church,” he said.

Cruz’s father was born on the reservation, bordered by the Rio Grande and today a 30-foot steel wall. His mother was Hispanic — a third-generation Socorro resident with Mexican and Spanish roots. His wife is from Mexico; their son learned the native tongue T’aiki in preschool. The family speaks Spanish and English at home.

“We are proud Americans and proud Texans,” Cruz said. “The mixture has become stronger between Mexico and me being American Indian.” He tells his son: “They have their traditions and ceremonies; we have our traditions and ceremonies.” They celebrate both.

Natividad keeps on his computer a portrait of his grandmother, Esperanza Almeida López Ochoa, an American citizen through marriage. In the photo she is young and fair, with red lips and dark hair swept up in 1940s-style victory rolls. In his native El Paso, Ochoa Street is named for his ancestors. Growing up, he often crossed the bridge to Ciudad Juárez with his mother and grandmother.

What sticks with him still: the way U.S. border guards grilled his grandmother — a U.S. citizen — “because she had an accent.” He remembers her cool head and his own anger. “She’s American!” he blurted. Today, as a border scholar, he wonders how his great-great-great grandfather navigated the changing expectations each new power exacted — the cultural and linguistic norms he had to learn or unlearn. And how the trauma of the past influences the present.

But border residents also know how to move between cultures and preserve them, Natividad added proudly. He quoted from memory the late Chicana author Gloria Anzaldúa, a Texan who wrote from the borderlands: “Voyager, there are no bridges, one builds them as one walks.”

“She hints that border residents are experts in bridge-building,” he said. “Because we see the border differently.”

This article originally appeared on USA TODAY: War redrew the US southern border. The culture never surrendered.

Share

This Post Has 0 Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!

Leave a Reply