Watchdog Says ChatGPT for Teens Safety Tools Fall Short, Urges Adult-Only Access

By Sophia Reynolds|Financial Markets Editor
•
Watchdog Says ChatGPT for Teens Safety Tools Fall Short, Urges Adult-Only Access

Some of the safety guardrails built into OpenAI's ChatGPT for Teens do not work as promised, and the chatbot poses an “unacceptable risk” to children, according to a report released Wednesday by Common Sense Media.

The watchdog group called on OpenAI to limit the chatbot to adults “until it can offer a safe, developmentally appropriate experience.” The report adds to growing scrutiny of how quickly conversational AI tools are reaching minors, and whether the safeguards meant to protect them can keep pace with the technology.

OpenAI pushed back, saying Common Sense Media's testing does not reflect how the chatbot's safeguards actually operate. The San Francisco company said a review of the report's methodology showed that “the bulk of their testing may have begun and concluded before activation of parental controls was complete, making their findings inaccurate.”

Parents, educators and child-development experts have raised alarms about children's use of AI chatbots. The tools have been blamed for facilitating cheating on schoolwork and, in extreme cases, suicide. Experts note that even adults can anthropomorphize AI and form unhealthy relationships with it, but teenagers' brains are still developing, making them particularly vulnerable.

Common Sense Media said some teen-mode features worked as intended, including the chatbot's refusal to engage in explicit sexual role-play. But it said other safeguards failed, including alerts intended to notify parents when a child is at risk of suicide, self-harm or an eating disorder, as well as support for teens in crisis.

“We are concerned that ChatGPT for Teens could give parents false confidence in guardrails that frequently don't work,” the report said. Common Sense Media advocates for the sensible use of digital media.

The group also said the chatbot still sounds like a friend when teens treat it like a person, even though OpenAI has promised to prevent it from suggesting it has personal feelings for users or implying that it is conscious or experiences emotions.

OpenAI said it is “deeply committed to teen safety” and is working on safeguards and tools that help parents guide their teens' use of AI. The dispute highlights a broader challenge for AI companies and families: safety modes and parental controls can be difficult for outside groups to audit, and independent testers may reach different conclusions depending on when and how they test.

Common Sense Media receives funding from OpenAI and other technology companies, including companies whose services it evaluates.

Share

This Post Has 0 Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!

Leave a Reply