Who Slowed Starshield? Ukraine’s Satellite Disruption Fuels GOP Demands and Contradictory Answers

By Emily Carter|Business & Economy Reporter
•
Who Slowed Starshield? Ukraine’s Satellite Disruption Fuels GOP Demands and Contradictory Answers

The question of who slowed a critical satellite communications system used by Ukraine—and why—has become a political flashpoint in Washington, with some Republicans demanding consequences and the Trump administration offering answers that have been incomplete, confusing and at times contradictory.

The controversy began a week ago when Ukraine accused Elon Musk’s SpaceX of severely hindering its defense by suddenly limiting its Starlink internet service, which uses satellites in low orbit. Ukraine has used Starlink and a related military-grade service, Starshield, to communicate quickly and to launch and prevent drone attacks.

Ukraine has also accused the Trump administration of limiting intelligence-sharing about impending Russian attacks, a charge the U.S. government denies.

What Ukraine and Zelensky say

Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky has pointed squarely at the Trump administration. In an interview Sunday on NBC’s “Meet the Press,” he said, “Of course the message came from government,” while adding that SpaceX carried out the order.

The next day, Zelensky sought to emphasize the human cost of such limits by posting a blurred image of a child he said was killed by a Russian Shahed drone.

Musk points toward Washington

Musk, the SpaceX CEO and a major Trump ally, also appeared to direct attention toward the U.S. government. Responding Wednesday on X to Ukraine’s former defense minister, Musk stressed that Starshield is “owned and controlled by the US government.” He added: “Any limits on speed or usage are decided by the US military and ultimately POTUS.”

When another X user claimed that “Starshield is under U.S. government control. That is who made last night’s call,” Musk replied: “True.”

SpaceX did not respond to a CNN question about whether Musk was explicitly confirming that Trump and his administration were responsible for the Starshield slowdown. His comments also appeared to leave some room for interpretation.

Administration denies involvement

The Trump administration has denied involvement and at times questioned whether any disruption occurred. Trump said flatly on Friday, “I didn’t do that.” He added: “I don’t know if it was anybody, because it wasn’t me, and I don’t think it was Elon.”

On Saturday, Secretary of State Marco Rubio suggested Zelensky did not know “what he’s talking about” and called reports of a White House role in the Starlink disruptions “categorically false.” Rubio said: “Nothing to do with the White House. No one at the White House ordered anyone to slow down internet or slow down speed so that certain drones couldn’t use it.”

Trump signaled Monday that he still did not know who was responsible. “I don’t know who it was, but I’d like to find out,” he said.

Those comments are difficult to reconcile with others. Trump on Friday also seemed to question whether there was a slowdown at all, saying he didn’t “even think it was slowed down” and that “I think it’s probably functioning.” He added: “They say it’s the same as it always has been.”

Rubio on Friday also claimed that Starshield was “not at this moment available to Ukraine” and “has nothing to do with Ukraine.” But Bloomberg reported two years ago that Ukraine had been given access to Starshield, and in comments Monday in Uzbekistan, Rubio confirmed that “Ukraine has benefited from it.”

A Reuters report and unresolved questions

Reuters reported Thursday, citing anonymous sources, that the White House sent a message to the Defense Department to slow the Starshield system. CNN has not confirmed that reporting. Multiple sources told CNN that the direction did not come from Trump, who has also denied being involved. Two senior U.S. officials told CNN that the Starshield order did not come from Trump.

Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth, in comments Tuesday after this article initially published, said the Pentagon “haven’t pulled anything back,” but added that “there are terms of service that obviously need to be complied to” when using Starlink—terms he said the government has the power to address.

Musk’s comments have also added to the confusion. While he appeared to point toward the administration and Trump on Starshield decisions, he said Starlink—the civilian version— “cannot be used for offensive military action, as doing so would be inappropriate for a commercial company.” That could be read as suggesting a dispute over Ukraine’s use of Starlink as well.

Why the timing matters

The episode did not unfold in a vacuum. It comes amid multiple signs that Trump is moving away from Ukraine and increasingly warming to Russia. Trump has blamed Ukraine’s strikes on Russian oil refineries for high diesel prices, despite compelling evidence that the Iran war is the main driver. He has recently delayed major new sanctions on Russia. And he has sought to import Russian diesel while pressing Ukraine to concede more to Moscow to end the war, which began with Russia’s unprovoked invasion in 2022.

The Starlink controversy also comes as Ukraine accuses the administration of withholding vital intelligence-sharing. The Trump administration denies that charge, although CNN has previously reported that it threatened to do just that.

Musk’s willingness to at least gesture toward Trump is notable given his role as a major Trump ally and the biggest benefactor of Trump’s political party in the midterm elections. He has spent hundreds of millions of dollars for the Republican Party. Musk could have said Starshield speed decisions are decided by the federal government and stopped there. Instead, he added, “and ultimately POTUS”—and then posted “True” in response to a user who said the U.S. government made the call.

Republicans demand answers

Amid the confusion, some congressional Republicans are demanding answers. They include retiring Rep. Don Bacon of Nebraska and vulnerable Rep. Brian Fitzpatrick of Pennsylvania. Fitzpatrick vowed Monday on X that those limiting Starshield “will be fully investigated and will be held fully accountable.” He also promised congressional hearings and “immediate harsh and punitive budget cuts to any responsible agency or agency head.”

Outgoing Sens. Thom Tillis of North Carolina and John Cornyn of Texas have joined Democrats in demanding accountability. Tillis called it either “an unacceptable error or lapse” or a conscious “decision to clear the field for a Russian attack.”

Answers may not be imminent, but the controversy could return to the fore if Democrats control one or both chambers of Congress come January.

Correction: This story has been updated to correct Rep. Brian Fitzpatrick’s first name.

Share

This Post Has 0 Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!

Leave a Reply