Costa Rica Votes Amidst Rising Crime and Disillusionment: A Nation's Social Fabric at a Crossroads

Lee el artículo en español

SAN JOSÉ — Costa Ricans went to the polls on Sunday in a presidential election that has laid bare deep-seated anxieties over surging crime, a fraying social safety net, and a growing disconnect between the political class and the public. With a record number of candidates vying for the presidency, the vote reflects a nation grappling with challenges that threaten its cherished model of stability.

Long celebrated as an oasis of peace in a turbulent region, Costa Rica is confronting a harsh new reality. Pre-election surveys consistently ranked citizen security as the top concern, a stark shift for a country that abolished its army in 1949. The backdrop to this election is a historic homicide rate—905 murders in 2023—linked by authorities to the nation's increasing role as a cocaine transshipment hub.

According to the latest polls from the University of Costa Rica's Center for Research and Political Studies (CIEP-UCR), former National Planning Minister Laura Fernández, 39, of the ruling party held a lead. However, with a quarter of voters undecided and a 40% threshold required to avoid a runoff, the outcome remained uncertain as voting concluded.

The security crisis is intertwined with broader social strains. "We are witnessing the weakening pillars of our social contract," said José Andrés Díaz González, a political scientist at Costa Rica's National University. "From healthcare and education to public safety, the foundations that ensured social mobility and cohesion are deteriorating."

This sentiment echoes a regional trend where crime dominates political agendas. The shadow of El Salvador's President Nayib Bukele and his controversial, iron-fist security model looms large. Last month, with Bukele's endorsement, Costa Rica broke ground on a prison modeled after his administration's facilities, a move praised by outgoing President Rodrigo Chaves.

Economically, the picture is contradictory. While macro indicators show growth, declining debt, and a booming tech export sector—buoyed by the country's 2021 OECD accession—this prosperity is not widely felt. "The growth is disconnected from people's well-being," noted Leonardo Merino, a political scientist with the State of the Nation Program (PEN). He highlighted that expansion is concentrated in tax-advantaged free trade zones, which employ only a fraction of the workforce, leaving the domestic economy behind.

This economic disconnect fuels a profound political apathy. Party affiliation has plummeted from near-universal levels three decades ago to about 20% today. Voter turnout hit a historic low in 2022, a trend experts warn is continuing. "Fewer people are voting. Young people are disengaged, and now even older adults are staying home," Merino observed.

The cumulative strain raises existential questions about Costa Rica's future direction. Its iconic environmental commitments now coexist with proposals to revisit bans on fossil fuel exploration. For analysts like Díaz and Merino, this election is a referendum on whether the country's political system can rebuild a fractured social pact and address the tensions mounting within its society.

Voices from the Public:

Carlos Mendez, 52, School Teacher in Heredia: "I voted, but without much hope. The debates were all about crime, but no one has a real plan for our schools or hospitals. We're losing what made Costa Rica special."

Ana Vega, 34, Small Business Owner in San José: "Fernández might bring order, but at what cost? Are we so desperate that we'll copy Bukele and throw away our democracy and human rights? That's not the solution; it's a surrender."

Felipe Cordero, 61, Retired Accountant in Puntarenas: "The violence is unacceptable. If building a tougher prison and taking a harder line keeps my family safe, I support it. The old way clearly isn't working anymore."

María Flores, 28, Environmental Activist in Limón: "It's heartbreaking. Our leaders talk about security and the economy while sidelining the climate crisis. We're risking our natural heritage for short-term gains. This election feels like a choice between bad and worse."

With ballots now being counted, the results will test not only which candidate can muster support but also whether Costa Rica's political institutions can bridge the gap with a disillusioned citizenry and navigate the profound challenges reshaping its future.

Reporting contributed from San José and Atlanta.